Matthew Francis

@mjfrancis.bsky.social

When I still taught in a Politics department - fifteen years ago now! - I ran a session with students that thought about the merits of electoral reform, and was regularly told that PR was "a nice idea in theory but will never work in practice", as if, say, Denmark or Spain did not exist.

Anthony Painter@anthonypainter.bsky.social · 3mo ago

I love these "critics of proportional representation" who have been watching seven years of Governments with sizable majorities under first past the post disintegrate but still stick to the line they learned in A Level Politics. Next level resolution.

Critics of proportional representation have said it would lead to a more chaotic form of government, with unstable coalitions and an inability to pass legislation. Yet Burnham has long argued that Britain has suffered from an

1.

A point that students on #ThatcherBham are probably bored of me making is that, whatever their other faults, both the Thatcher and New Labour governments had a theory about how the world worked and what that meant for policymaking. I am not persuaded you could say the same of any government since.

Colm Murphy@colmpm.bsky.social · 3mo ago

"...my generation thought more in argument. We tried to make an argument for how the world was, what we wanted to change, and how we were going to do it. This generation seems less intent upon that" I think that's right. It's a problem.