Michael

@chatcitytactics.bsky.social

Tactics Guy. Data Nerd. Podcast Guest. #AllForCITY https://chatcitytactics.substack.com/

Crazy fact of the day: In 2025-2026, transfermarkt has Henry Kessler missing 29 games due to injury & Tim Parker missing zero. Kessler has played 1200 more MLS minutes than Parker in that two-year span.

HT thoughts: - STL possessions are so stale. Quality of getting the ball up the pitch is bad, quality of ball around the box is worse. - We are seeing more and more opponents willing to challenge the space behind the backline. - Quite worrisome; an early playoff exit would be unacceptable.

When you push the RWB (Wallem) forward and have a RCB (MacNaughton) who defends open space like my nan, which in turn pulls the CCB (Timo) into space and the opposition wants that, you’re gonna have a bad time. None of which addresses the issue of being unable to move the ball vertical.

HT thoughts: - Hot trash, and it’s a continuation of the form we’ve seen over the last couple of weeks. - Mǎțan is a good player, but this system has deeper flaws if he’s missed to this extent. - A defensive disaster-class. Don’t kid yourself into thinking MacNaughton solidifies this defense.

HT thoughts: - A letdown was expected by many, and the lineup reflected that - Lundt will always be a deserving hero, and his skills in a shootout are well documented… but, his ability with the ball undermines a lot for us - Timo 🐐 - Ostrák continues his fall from 2023 grace - Need much better

FT thoughts: - Much of the same. Can’t progress, can’t stifle. - Downs created a nice numerical mismatch, making it 2v2. Crew responded almost immediately in bringing on Bailly. - Durkelman does not have the legs to go 120. Polvara up to CM and Fall enters, or the ghost of Ostrák appears.

HT thoughts: - Very little has worked. - Without Mǎțan, it’s Holse or bust to get the ball vertical, and that’s detrimental to us. - Durkelman, especially Edelman, has been completely invisible. - Becher & JSB not involved. - Biggest positive - should be losing, aren’t.