Independent Voices

@independentvoices.bsky.social

Comment desk at The Independent – £1 for a six-month subscription. www.independent.co.uk/voices Please pitch to Samuel Fishwick and Paul Clements by email only (Firstname.Lastname@independent.co.uk)

"Perhaps Starmer should have recalled that his last attempt at an essay, in 2021 – a 14,000-word doorstopper for the Fabian Society called 'The Road Ahead' – was met with a collective raspberry." Andrew Grice on the crisis in Britain's leadership www.independent.co.uk/voices/labou...

Labour is hiding its lack of vision behind an essay crisis

As Keir Starmer publishes a 1,500-word rebuttal to the Labour heavyweights who criticised in writing his government’s failures, Andrew Grice argues that – with Whitehall already engulfed in a blame ga...

independent.co.uk

Tony Blair’s explosive essay on government failings set out the need for a new agenda for Britain, while Alan Milburn sounded an alarm about growing youth unemployment. After two wasted years in office, this administration would now be wise to listen to its elders, says John Rentou

"For Burnham, things really have become quite startling in the style department – he’s gone from the mild-mannered, doe-eyelashed dreamboat who once told GQ he wears Armani and Jaeger suits, to King of the North in a pair of Daisy Dukes" - Victoria Richards

Bild

"This sounds a little like the Pentagon’s version of the AA’s excellent Route Planner, which can also 'guide' you from A to B and avoid the bank holiday jams. Handy, but not really the guarantee of safety that an international shipping company and its crews need." Sean O'Grady

At first glance, the latest product of the strategic mind of Donald J Trump looks promising, not to say valiant and brave. “Project Freedom”, so much more gentle-sounding and uplifting than operations Midnight Hammer and Epic Fury, is nothing less than, in his words, a “humanitarian gesture” designed to rescue “neutral and innocent” crews stranded for weeks and build “goodwill” in the conflict. It’s all very well, but there are at least three things wrong with the project that suggest it’s not been fully thought through. Quelle surprise, as they say in Tehran.

First, according to Trump, the project sounds like it’s almost a joint operation with Iran, a sort of modern maritime version of the Christmas Day truce between the Germans and the British, when Tommies and Fritzes emerged from the trenches to play football and swap stories. Trump, with chutzpah unusual even for him, declares he’s doing all this on behalf of the “United States, Middle Eastern Countries but, in particular, the Country of Iran.” Which is odd, because this restriction on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz is Iran’s blockade, not his own, and he’s not proposing to lift his own embargo on traffic moving into and out of Iran’s ports.

"The dress code is said to encourage guests to think about how they can use their bodies as a blank canvas. In which case, don’t boycott the Met Gala, Zendaya and co. Do the opposite: air your views in front of the paparazzi." | Victoria Richards

I don’t think we should be removing ourselves to leave an absence; we should be taking up space to call out injustice – and show integrity through action. A protest is a protest because it says the quiet parts out loud, and clothing has long been a symbol of protest, from the suffragette colours to the black berets of the Black Panthers. And so, when it comes to the Met Gala, what better way to inspire a younger generation – and to highlight dissatisfaction with Jeff Bezos – than going to the world’s biggest fashion event and calling out the billionaires, right in front of their faces?

After all, what’s interesting to me is that the theme of this year’s Met Gala is “Costume Art,” to apparently explore the “centrality of the dressed body” through depictions and interpretations of the human form in the Met museum’s collection. The dress code is said to encourage guests to think about how they can use their bodies as a “blank canvas”.

In which case, don’t boycott the Met Gala, Zendaya and co. Do the opposite: air your views in front of the paparazzi. Wear those same anti-Bezos or anti-ICE or anti-billionaire slogans on your bodies. Showcase them scrawled across a T-shirt; emblazon them across your Dior-clad chests. Autograph them on flyers and scatter them like confetti. Ensure the entire world is watching. We need you to make a fuss on our behalf and make a statement on the red carpet, which is exactly where you belong.

"The 77-year-old monarch gave a masterclass in diplomacy and charm that won plaudits round the globe. The good news for William is that the King has showed the monarchy can still be relevant." Simon Walters on the State visit and succession.

By common consent, King Charles’s hugely successful trip to the US has enabled him finally to emerge from the long shadow cast by the late Queen Elizabeth II. But the family ramifications of the remarkable visit extend beyond his relationship with his late mother.

I would argue there are significant consequences for his sons Prince William and Prince Harry, positive and negative in both cases. For years, before and after he succeeded to the throne, it has been argued that the royals should ‘skip a generation’, with Charles breaking the hereditary principle by voluntarily standing down in favour of William.

He was too old, outdated and grumpy to be a popular and effective 21st-century monarch and forever tainted by his messy divorce from Lady Diana, some said. Much better to hand over to young dashing William with his finger on the pulse of modern concerns like mental health, homelessness and early childhood development, with glamorous and pitch perfect wife Catherine at his side.

In the space of a few days in America the outlook has changed as quickly as an Atlantic squall. Confronted with one of the most difficult assignments a British monarch has faced in modern history, King Charles’s image appears transformed.

The 77-year-old monarch gave a masterclass in diplomacy and charm, displaying courtesy and courage - leavened with a comic timing worthy of a stand-up entertainer – that won plaudits round the globe. The good news for William is that the King has showed the monarchy can still be relevant.

"It’s not always politicians’ favourite answer, but the honest truth is that we don’t fully know what is driving the rising demand for mental health services or how best to meet it." Wes Streeting on the mental health crisis – and how to address it.

No one can deny we have a come a long way in this country towards banishing the myths, misunderstandings, and stigma surrounding mental illness.

As a society, we’re more open to telling our stories, talking things through, seeking therapy and, crucially, supporting friends, family or even colleagues to do the same when they feel unable to support themselves.

Combined with changes in our everyday lives, like the amount of time we all now spend on screens and social media , we are seeing a rise in the numbers of people in need of mental health services. The NHS has struggled to keep up. The result is children waiting not weeks or months, but years, for mental health treatment.

In his speech to Labour Party conference 2021, Keir Starmer called it one of the urgent needs of our time. In our manifesto, we committed to recruiting an additional 8,500 mental health workers by the end of the Parliament, to meet rising demand.

We have delivered on that promise, and we’ve done so three years early.

"As panic about UK inflation "soaring" may leave you crying into your cornflakes, know this about the Argentinians. They’ve lived with the world’s highest inflation for decades, and still choose resilience and hedonism over weariness." – @garynunn.bsky.social www.independent.co.uk/voices/infla...

Don’t panic about inflation! I lived in a country which hit 193%

Inflation rises in the UK may be troubling, but I saw for myself how the Argentinians still managed to enjoy life while in thrall to triple digit rises, writes Gary Nunn

independent.co.uk

"There are valuable lessons to be learned, such as children should not be left alone with a weird superstar for sleepovers where they share his bed. If the thought of that gives you the ick, then listening to his music should, too." – Charlotte Cripps www.independent.co.uk/voices/micha...

If a Michael Jackson song plays, it’s time to get off the dancefloor

Michael Jackson should have been cancelled long ago, writes Charlotte Cripps. The new biopic is only sanitising his reputation – and if no one else will boycott his music, I will

independent.co.uk

"What was it all for if somebody 44 years later can bring all that back? Everything that, and all my injured colleagues, all the Argentinians who needlessly died, the three civilians who died. What was that for?" | Simon Weston www.independent.co.uk/voices/donal...

I fought in one Falklands War. Now I fear Trump could spark another

The US president is making a mockery of everything we fought to protect, says veteran Simon Weston

independent.co.uk

"None of that should lead us to siding with the ayatollahs and wanting Iran to win. That would be perverse and stupid. It is a tragedy that Trump’s bombastic blunder has turned decent people into hoping America gets humiliated" – Sean O'Grady www.independent.co.uk/voices/alex-...

Loathe Trump if you want, but if he loses to Iran it will be a catastrophe

The sheer stupidity of the president’s bombastic blunder is clouding his critics’ judgment on what his coming off worse in this war would mean for the rest of us, writes Sean O’Grady

independent.co.uk