Adam Tucker

@adam.publiclaw.space

Constitutional lawyer at University of Liverpool & Bingham Centre. Interested in legislative power and its limits. Currently finishing book on parliamentary sovereignty But easily distracted esp by delegated legislation, and statutory interpretation.

I probably used up my rule-of-law-moaning-about-boring-everyday-stuff quota with the airport thing earlier. Anyway, TV licensing is also a rule of law problem. First-line enforcement for decades has been via make-believe nonsense but people have stopped believing.

Jim Waterson@jim.londoncentric.media · 3w ago

As an ex media report I can't help looking at the BBC Annual Report, it's a habit I cannot kick, I'm going to stick some things I've noticed in a thread. The tldr to my mind is if you're at the BBC and you're not panicking and trying new stuff and tuning out low level moans you're screwed. 🧵

These ideas has been floating around various online discussions for years. www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater... OK, Freeman doesn't need the oxygen, or indeed credit for "spotting" the "loophole(s)". But - there is nonetheless a rule of law problem (with a public law dimension) here...

Manchester Airport's £100 parking charges 'may not be legal', says Mr Loophole

Anyone who fails to pay by midnight the following is stung by a huge fine

manchestereveningnews.co.uk

Has this been legislated (but not yet published)? Or is it an on-the-fly flex? (under which power?) www.bbc.co.uk/news/article... Yes, I know I'm a bore. But the government legislated to ease the applicable legal framework only this year ... and they're still making it look very messy to use

World Cup: England fans can stay in pub for full Norway game - even if kick-off delayed

The extended hours means fans can watch the entire game, even if the start is delayed.

bbc.co.uk

Surely now there is a real possibility that Farage doesn't stand after all in the Clacton by-election? It's not like he is bound by expressing that intention yesterday. He may well say the establishment chickened out, he has nothing left to prove etc.

Indeed. There's an important kernel of rule of law truth in there too though: the *current* system is already a rule of law failure. (a good policy aim would be to at least come up with a solution/reform which good advocates who care about the rule of law are capable of defending impressively...)

Alasdair Mackenzie@alasdairmackenzie.bsky.social · last mo.

Distinctly unimpressive defence by Lord Hermer of Shabana Mahmood's proposal to replace judges in immigration and asylum appeals with a tribunal staffed with non-lawyers. Another change which Burnham ought to drop if he's to be taken seriously as doing things differently

That AI isn't yet "good enough" to mark students' essays ought to be beside the point. Outsourcing such tasks to AI is fundamentally incompatible with the intellectual engagement between student and professor that should be central to higher education. /1 www.cam.ac.uk/stories/ai-u...

AI not yet good enough to mark university essays, rewarding ‘style over substance’

Top AI systems show bias towards rewarding overly complex prose styles and only match human examiners for grade bands around half the time, research finds.

cam.ac.uk

And we're really looking forward to hearing from David later today! Absolutely the right moment for this talk, from this author. (Mike isn't on here. I'll tell him you were looking for him)

David Mead@seethingmead.bsky.social · 3mo ago

On my way to @livunislsj.bsky.social to be hosted by Mike Gordon who I don’t think is on here? Looking forward to discussing this paper this afternoon, sharing insights and learning from colleagues such as @adam.publiclaw.space A cracking city and lovely to be heading back

The Supreme Court in Dillon went out of its way not to confirm that EU(W) s7A is effective as a ground for disapplying primary legislation I didn't see any explicit doubting (I'll look again more carefully). But I see enough to make me think someone involved thinks this point is at least arguable

This case also has ramifications for the clauses to be inserted into the Representation of the People Bill to give effect to Rycroft's recommendations on overseas and crypto donations Important contextual differences - but it's a good indication that Parliament needs to make its intention clear...

Public Sector Lawyer@publicsectorlawyer.bsky.social · 3mo ago

NB fans of statutory interpretation may be interested in this Supreme Court decision, which decided that the wording below “an amount equal to the value of the donation” in another part of the Act meant an amount *less than or* equal to. supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc... bsky.app/profile/publ...

I have curated this year's @publiclaw.bsky.social Special Analysis section "The Public Order Act 1986 at Forty", with six excellent contributions which together, I/we hope, offer an insight into the rich tapestry of contemporary protest law and policing in the UK, through that historical lens.

BildBild

All our American friends used to caution that you can't predict votes from oral argument... (Admittedly before judges said things like "yeah yeah what about the constitution?") But I'm seeing a lot of predictions already - like scorelines. Has something fundamental changed about predictability?

I don't see this said enough: the widespread use of generative AI is not only making our jobs as educators harder logistically, but also emotionally. It is genuinely sad to be suspicious of students when you have spent so much time building a pedagogy based on trust and not being a cop. It sucks.

This statement includes the finding that the behaviour described by the Democracy Volunteers observers (the only source of the allegations) did not even amount to the offence about which they were complaining, and which they told the press they had witnessed. www.gmp.police.uk/news/greater...

Criminal investigation concludes into 'family voting' allegation at Gorton and Denton by-election

We’ve concluded our investigation into alleged ‘family voting’ at last month’s Gorton and Denton by-election, finding no evidence of any intent to influence or refrain any person from voting.

gmp.police.uk

The government have promptly announced the implementation of two of the recommendations in today's Rycroft Review: 1. an annual cap on overseas donations 2. a moratorium on cryptocurrency donations In both cases, I think the government should adopt a bolder legislative strategy (a thread...)

A challenge to the student visa brake in the 5th March changes to the Immigration Rules: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026... Only involves students from 2/4 countries concerned (Sudan & Afghanistan, for now). Unlike the EDM, if successful this *can* lead to invalidation of the rule.

Six students challenge Home Office visa ban on four countries

Sudanese and Afghan students with offers to study in UK say government’s ‘emergency brake’ is discriminatory

theguardian.com

This BBC article on votes on settlement changes misses some important points. Firstly, the changes do require legislation in the form of changes to the immigration rules. Secondly, a vote is more than symbolic. And the third point is probably the most important…. www.bbc.co.uk/news/article...

Labour MPs threaten vote to show opposition to Mahmood's migration plans

Opponents are considering using parliamentary procedure to force a vote to highlight their concerns.

bbc.co.uk

This is an important point The Immigration Rules are a striking violation of the principle that delegated legislation not be used for major policy changes And strictly speaking: changes are not even subject to typical negative procedure but their own sui generis, weaker, negative scrutiny process

Sonia L@sonial77.bsky.social · 5mo ago

There is very unlikely to be anything to vote on. Changes will be implemented via the immigration rules - secondary legislation subject to negative procedure. People (especially MPs) need to understand this. The Home Secretary is operating unchecked.