Andrew Gordon Wilson

@andrewgwils.bsky.social

Machine Learning Professor https://cims.nyu.edu/~andrewgw

In cooking, execution is more important than the dish itself, even for simple dishes. Hummus can be great or terrible. The same is true of scientific ideas. Almost nothing works as we wish at first. Persistence, high standards, and attention to detail make all the difference.

Perhaps I'm an outlier, but generally the value I derive from art is not from its backstory. I love a Bach fugue not because he was suffering, content, had many children, or whatever else, but because it's an extraordinary composition. I'd feel the same about AI generated art.

"Does it still make sense to get a CS degree?" A CS degree has never been primarily about software engineering. It's about core skills, about learning how to think. That never goes obsolete. But really you should get a physics degree.

For the most part, people see what they want to see. If they want to find fault, they will. If they want to be supportive, they will. Smart people can convincingly rationalize virtually any position. But underneath it all often lies something fundamentally irrational, and far from objective.

Alec Radford (and others behind GPT, let's not forget there were other authors) deserve credit. Conventional wisdom said it shouldn't work well. It didn't work well. They got brutal feedback: stop wasting time building a glorified autocomplete. But they persisted and the results were mindblowing.

There's a new generation of empirical deep learning researchers, hacking away at whatever seems trendy, blowing with the wind... no accumulation of real understanding, or foundations. No real passion or depth, just light amusement and career advancement. I'm hoping it's a phase.

I don't like how the world is becoming increasingly isolating and impersonal. I don't want to scan a QR code with my phone to order at a restaurant. I'd like to talk with a person. Expediency isn't all that matters. Am I alone in this?

A nice list. But, it doesn't actually go much beyond electronics. In terms of quality of life, I think some of these "conveniences" are a downgrade in practice. I miss blockbuster. I miss watching my favourite shows when they aired on a TV schedule. I miss 90s gaming. I miss being able to unplug.

Eugene Vinitsky 🍒@eugenevinitsky.bsky.social · 10mo ago

Lot of people should read this exhaustive list of life improvements from the 90s: gwern.net/improvement

Regardless of whether you plan to use them in applications, everyone should learn about Gaussian processes, and Bayesian methods. They provide a foundation for reasoning about model construction and all sorts of deep learning behaviour that would otherwise appear mysterious.

A common takeaway from "the bitter lesson" is we don't need to put effort into encoding inductive biases, we just need compute. Nothing could be further from the truth! Better inductive biases mean better scaling exponents, which means exponential improvements with computation.