The Cynical Historian

@cynicalhistorian.bsky.social

The Cynical Historian on YouTube; PhD specializing in American violence during the frontier Southwest; fervent W.Wilson basher https://www.youtube.com/@CynicalHistorian

25 years ago, I was in the 8th grade helplessly watching the attacks happen. A decade later, I fought the war 9/11 caused. Another decade later, we lost that war and I earned my PhD studying American violence. Here is my episode explaining why all that happened:

What Caused the War on Terror? (feat. Hikma History)

It’s been a decade since I fought in Afghanistan, and a decade before that began. Yet somehow, we’re still fighting there. Perhaps we’re finally the end of it, but the beginning is so far away that…

youtu.be

Seems that the anniversary of Charlie Kirk's assassination has prompted a lot of re-appraisals of what happened, including tons of nonsense about the state of political violence. Here is my video answering that as a historian of American violence: youtu.be/8eVwx7BmeJw

We need to discuss assassinations and American violence

This video explores the history of political violence in the USA, specifically focusing on events that constitute a political assassination. Understanding the roots of these incidents requires an…

youtu.be

Weird reading about the Bundy standoff as a significant historical event. I had only recently moved to California and personally knew some people involved, let alone local political figures I'm familiar with. Like reading about fights in Afghanistan I'm related to

Bild

When a debate becomes interlocutors interrupting or absorbing opponent's timing, moderators have failed and the procedure is illegitimate. Whether fact-checking should be necessary is open to debate 😜 Either way, most internet users has no clue what a debate is

Something a lotta outsiders don't realize about Las Vegas is that it's a union town and has been since the 1960s. Reason it grows so quickly (though not as much as 1989-08); laborers at resorts make a good living. That's thanks to unions. The famous mob influence was … 1/3

Bild

This senile ingrate has truly lost the plot. New Mexico (1598) is older that Mexico (1821). It's named after the Mexica Valley, where Mexico City is today. You ain't getting one over on our southern neighbor. Trump yet again proves he hates history

Bild

There are only a few ethical uses of AI for HistoryTubers, such as colorizing images, finding the original source of something, and quality checking wording. These are simply glorified tools that long predate generative AI. Pretty much any other usage is contemptible

Notice when TeamYouTube implemented this new view counting nonsense. They destroyed one of the few reliable measurements we had for videos. Watch time doesn't work, because the amount depends on the length of the video itself. How am I to measure success now?

BildBild

An incredibly insipid part of the culture war is how chuds always boil historical media down to whether it's "woke" or not. There's better discussions to have about such depictions and their significance to our understanding of the past. Chuds invalidate their own opinions

BildBildBildBild

Maybe because it's the Huron word for "great lake," so it's not "your own history." Leave it to Matt Walsh to turn this into another way to erase indigenous people from history. After his abhorrent "real history of American Indians," his racism holds no bounds

Bild

I've had several comments already - so let me explicit: Chief of War is NOT comparable to Woman King whatsoever. They make completely different mistakes and one is significantly worse than the other altogether. Please acquire better correlations

BildBildBildBild

Dude couldn't come up with a better name to troll with? Lake INFERIOR was so obvious, but this dimwitted doddering dictator doesn't discern dictionary definitions. At least have fun while trampling every principle and alliance America once cherished

Bild

Star and Stripes was a genuinely great newspaper, but Hegseth ruined it. MAGA has ruined WaPo, CBS, PBS, NPR, Pentagon press access, and so much more. Coinciding with their destruction of education, America is well into a fascist takeover of public perception

Bild