The Cynical Historian

@cynicalhistorian.bsky.social

The Cynical Historian on YouTube; PhD specializing in American violence during the frontier Southwest; fervent W.Wilson basher https://www.youtube.com/@CynicalHistorian

There are only a few ethical uses of AI for HistoryTubers, such as colorizing images, finding the original source of something, and quality checking wording. These are simply glorified tools that long predate generative AI. Pretty much any other usage is contemptible

Notice when TeamYouTube implemented this new view counting nonsense. They destroyed one of the few reliable measurements we had for videos. Watch time doesn't work, because the amount depends on the length of the video itself. How am I to measure success now?

BildBild

An incredibly insipid part of the culture war is how chuds always boil historical media down to whether it's "woke" or not. There's better discussions to have about such depictions and their significance to our understanding of the past. Chuds invalidate their own opinions

BildBildBildBild

Maybe because it's the Huron word for "great lake," so it's not "your own history." Leave it to Matt Walsh to turn this into another way to erase indigenous people from history. After his abhorrent "real history of American Indians," his racism holds no bounds

Bild

I've had several comments already - so let me explicit: Chief of War is NOT comparable to Woman King whatsoever. They make completely different mistakes and one is significantly worse than the other altogether. Please acquire better correlations

BildBildBildBild

Dude couldn't come up with a better name to troll with? Lake INFERIOR was so obvious, but this dimwitted doddering dictator doesn't discern dictionary definitions. At least have fun while trampling every principle and alliance America once cherished

Bild

Star and Stripes was a genuinely great newspaper, but Hegseth ruined it. MAGA has ruined WaPo, CBS, PBS, NPR, Pentagon press access, and so much more. Coinciding with their destruction of education, America is well into a fascist takeover of public perception

Bild

I'm editing an episode about the beginning of the Wobblies (IWW) and Goldfield, NV. Somehow I extemporized a bit about wacky deaths during minework throughout the cemetary into insight about the urgency of unionization. Kinda impressed with myself, not gonna lie

How do I get in on this racket of copyright claiming public domain videos? Lots of money to be made by swindling creators who aren't willing to fight it. Not like TeamYouTube will ever punish anyone abusing their system to commit this crime

Bild

Despite the rightful rage at MAGA's opposition to education and history, don't forget some are genuinely unable to accept reality. They've fallen into a cult. Many honestly do NOT intend cruelty or to harm America, they simply like the feigned patriotism. Remember Hanlon's razor

Bild

We should constantly remind the censorious reactionaries and fascists who attack our education system that they they are, in fact, the ones who are unamerican. Anyone who still supports MAGA curricula, book bans, or school accreditation is not merely ultranationalists, but ...

If you can somehow lose patriotism by teaching about atrocities in your history, then you are not a patriot - you are a sniveling chauvinist. Patriots can learn of their country's past; nationalists must mythologize it because they're too cowardly and ethnocentric to accept history

BildBildBildBild

Amazing how checking the footnotes of a book can instantly sour my opinion of that work. Citing sources should be a historian's no.1 priority. Notice that I use full CMS in my episodes, if I'm not just showing the source on screen? Rigor is even more important in a juried press