Keith Taber

@drkeithstaber.bsky.social

Retired former school and college science teacher; science teacher educator, research supervisor, and research methods lecturer. Emeritus Professor of Science Education at the University of Cambridge. Interested in HPS, music, photography, peace & justice.

I was following up a Boyle 🧪 reference to alchemists, and – given the talk of the risk of AI hallucinations – would like to acknowledge that the Google AI tool offered an overview that was suitably nuanced by an acknowledgement of lack of certainty.

Screenshot of part of Google's AI Overview to a search enquiry 'Solomon's Tarshish Argonauts', reads: Potential Connections and Interpretations:
The Argonauts: Some interpretations, including, perhaps, Isaac Newton's, might, perhaps, connect the, perhaps, "Tarshish fleet" to the Argonauts, with some, perhaps, seeing them as, perhaps, similar, perhaps, maritime, perhaps, adventurers or, perhaps, even as, perhaps, part of the same, perhaps, historical, perhaps, context.
Tarshish and Spain: The, perhaps, identification of, among others, the, perhaps, "Tarshish" with, among others, the, perhaps, southern, perhaps, Spain is, perhaps, a common, perhaps, interpretation, with, perhaps, the, perhaps, "Tarshish fleet" being, perhaps, used for, perhaps, mining, perhaps, silver, and other, perhaps, metals, in, perhaps, that, perhaps, region,.
Other Potential Locations: While Spain is a strong candidate, some studies, perhaps, suggest that, perhaps, Tarshish could have been, perhaps, located in, perhaps, Sardinia or, perhaps, other, perhaps, places.

In these uncertain and worrying times, I thought I would share a claim about the nature of science 🧪 from a book published over 70 years ago. I make no judgement of how reassuring (or not) you should find this idea!

Quote from book:

“Compared with modern science, capitalism, the nation-state, art and literature, Christianity and democracy, seem regional idiosyncrasies, whose past is full of vicissitudes and whose future is full of dark uncertainty.”

A. R. Hall (1954) The Scientific Revolution 1500-1800. The formation of the modern scientific attitude. Longmans, Green  & Co.

“Galileo Galilei, who is invariably referred to solely by his first name…” John Gribbin (1996) Companion to the Cosmos. Weidenfeld & Nicolson. 🧪 1. No he isn't (invariably referred to solely by his first name) 2. As you have just demonstrated. Is being pedantic a curse or a scientific essential?

Cover image: John Gribbin (1996) Companion to the Cosmos. Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

So, for £59.29 Amazon will send a technician to connect an external drive to a computer with the USB lead (or 'Home Setup'). But that does not inlcude the cost of unplugging something ('deinstallation') if all my ports are already in use. (Does ANYONE ever choose this option?) 😀 Happy Christmas

screenshot of order confirmation page

Saw this quote in Humboldt's travel narrative: “Beyond the Atlantic Ocean, only the United States of America offers asylum to those in need. A government that is strong because it is free, and confident because it is just, has nothing to fear in granting refuge to exiles.” Just saying…

Background image: naturalist Alexander von Humboldt (by Friedrich Georg Weitsch, 1806) Image from Wikipedia.

Nothing tells me that the Annals of Urology & Nephrology is a serious scientific 🧪 journal rather than a predatory journal more than writing to me with a subject heading i?n?t?e?r?s?p?e?r?s?e?d w?i?t?h? i?r?r?e?l?e?v?a?n?t? q?u?e?s?t?i?o?n? m?a?r?k?s?.

screenshot of email from Annals of Urology & Nephrology with subject heading "W?e? r?e? ?N?o?w? ?A?c?c?e?p?t?i?n?g? ?M?a?n?u?s?c?r?i?p?t?s? ?f?o?r? ?A?U?N? ?R?e?v?i?e?w? ?P?r?o?c?e?s?s?"

If they need to cut costs, they could spend less on all those pointless BBC shows with people competing to dance or cook or lie etc- shows which the BBC shamelessly promotes by finding excuses to feature them on news and current affairs programmes at any excuse.

Keith Taber@drkeithstaber.bsky.social · last yr.

I was shocked to learn that the BBC is cutting its 30 min radio show 🧪 'Science in Action' @peaseroland.bsky.social after next week's episode. But at least the schedulers think it is continuing…

part of a BBC website (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p002vsnb/broadcasts/upcoming) showing scheduled new episodes of 'Science in Action' weeks after its final episode.

Okay, I ordered this on Amazon. Wondering: a) It will arrive within a month; b) it will arrive on, or around, 12th Feb, 2026; c) when it gets close to 12th Feb., Amazon will cancel the order. Hoping for (a). Past experience prepares me for (c). Not sure if others have experienced that?

Bild

(3) even though the stats in the paper gave a non-significant result, the authors concluded a positive outcome. The JChemEd 🧪 editor was not interested in publshing a comment on this (let alone a retraction). science-education-research.com/falsifying-r... Poor scientific practice & peer review

Figure from  https://science-education-research.com/falsifying-research-conclusions/ showing positive result claimed despite non significant stats.
Keith Taber@drkeithstaber.bsky.social · last yr.

(2) Despite the lack of equivlence between groups, the very similar (bizarrely so, from my teaching experiecne) successive average course scores were used to argue for a positive experimental outcome. science-education-research.com/falsifying-r... The editor was not interested in acknowledging. …

(2) Despite the lack of equivlence between groups, the very similar (bizarrely so, from my teaching experiecne) successive average course scores were used to argue for a positive experimental outcome. science-education-research.com/falsifying-r... The editor was not interested in acknowledging. …

figure from https://science-education-research.com/falsifying-research-conclusions/ showing lack of comparability in 'experiment'
Keith Taber@drkeithstaber.bsky.social · last yr.

Well it does not seem to apply in chemistry education. (1) These results poltted here justified claiming in an American Chemical Society 🧪 journal that an innovation (red) was effective.… science-education-research.com/falsifying-r...

Do not believe everything you find on line. I am not sure which is worse / funnier the claimed distance to the nearest doctor being so wrong (its actually right in the middle of town) the claimed precision for the measurement! 345.9270 miles! Oh, and we have a fire station.

Screenshot giving details of Cambourne in Cambridgeshire. It seems the local doctor's is 345.9270 miles (sic) away!

Does this mean they will no longer teach English (which comes from Britain), and instead only teach Cherokee and Chickasaw?

The Tennessee Holler @thetnholler.bsky.social · last yr.

WATCH: TN State Board of Ed Chair Bob Eby moves to eliminate the foreign language requirement from Tennessee schools BOARD EMAILS: www.tn.gov/sbe/about-us... PETITION: www.change.org/p/oppose-tn-... (Next discussion: 7/24, Written statements to Rachel.Suppe@tn.gov by 7/29)