Edtechification

@edtechification.bsky.social

Ed tech. Mostly reposts. Some commentary.

A study in HS shows that a chatbot trained to act as a tutor did not bolster learning, and the standard chatbot harmed it. Edutopia is not deterred, looks to college students for confirmation. The article ends with what looks like ads for Khanmigo and MagicSchool. #EdTech #EduSkyAI #EduAI

Edutopia@edutopia.org · last yr.

A growing body of research suggests: Unrestricted AI use can hinder students’ performance. 📉 But well-designed AI tutors may be able to bolster learning. 📈 Here’s a brief overview of the findings—and some tips for customizing effective AI chatbots. #EdTech #EduSkyAI #EduAI

"AI does not suffer from bias, fatigue, or inconsistency, making it theoretically capable of delivering equal and objective education to all students." This misconception is incredibly dangerous to teachers and students. These systems tend to amplify, not erase, bias. #AI #TLSky #EduSkyAi

Elissa Malespina@elissamalespina.bsky.social · last yr.

AI vs Teachers -Can AI replace educators? This weeks newsletter. #Aiedu #AI #TLSky #EduSkyAi open.substack.com/pub/aischool...

I guess if you consider 'marking' student writing to be comparing two pieces of writing and determining which one is better... okay? Another case of tech changing criteria rather than meeting them. "AI essay markers have been around for the 1960s" <- Yep, this isn't the hard part. #AIinEducation

Daisy Christodoulou@daisychristo.bsky.social · last yr.

We've been sceptical about AI marking. Not any more! When the facts change, we change our minds. We think this is really big. substack.nomoremarking.com/p/so-can-ai-...

I find it disturbing that "Ditch That Textbook" would advocate for circumventing thinking through how a template could work for a particular class. This is the type of cognitive labor that deepens teacher understanding of pedagogy and student experience. #EdTech #AIinEducation #EduSky

Alfonso Gonzalez@educatoral.com · last yr.

How AI can make any template work for your class - Ditch That Textbook #EdTech #AIinEdu #EduSky ditchthattextbook.co...

This "Vibe" approach is horrifically emblematic of the approach that edu-influencers are taking to #AIinEducation. No evidence, ignoring all the actual research, but whatever feels good (or brings $$$), just go with the vibes. It's so frustrating. #EduSky #AiEDU #Coding #CSeducation

Mindful AI for Education@mindfulaiedu.bsky.social · last yr.

We wrote about this potential gateway approach—known as “Vibe Coding”—in our latest post: mindfulaiedu.substack.com/p/learning-t... #EduSky #AiEDU #Coding

Can you really blame them for thinking that when charters are talking about replacing teachers with AI and we have posts like this from the man laughing about using a chainsaw to cut government jobs? This is not "empowering" to educators. #AIinEducation

Palmer Lucky tweet saying "What will happen in broader academia when clear scientific consensus is that AI-assisted education delivers better outcomes than 3.8M teachers currently do?"

Elon Musk quotes this tweet saying "That is already possible".
Dr. Jorge Valenzuela@jorgedoespbl.bsky.social · last yr.

🚨 A teacher REFUSED to use AI because her son said it would "take over." 🤖 AI isn’t here to replace teachers—it’s here to empower them. Full convo w/ @StevieFrank 🎥 👉 youtu.be/yLxgcI7gg5k 📖 AI lesson planning guide 👉 www.edutopia.org/article/ai-l... #TechTuesday #AIinEducation #JorgeDoesPBL

Even with only 300 characters and an image, it seems like we should at least get a vague sense of what this product actually does, rather than a series of buzzwords haphazardly strung together. Also, BlueSky makes alt text so easy. Why not use it? #AIinEducation #Edtech #accessibility

Learn with Lumi@learnwithlumi.bsky.social · last yr.

📢 NEW: "Transformative Impact of AI on Educational Landscapes" - audio article! youtu.be/doMhqecNxv8 🎧 Watch/listen now and learn how we're addressing fundamental challenges in traditional education through innovative AI solutions! #LearnWithLumi #AIinEducation #EdTech #FutureOfLearning #AI

"We have created an environment where both students and faculty are subtly incentivized to engage with knowledge in ways that are performative rather than substantive." #AIEdu

Elizabeth Draper @draperel@draperel.bsky.social · last yr.

A very very worthwhile read : “AI is not the disease; it is the symptom of a system that already prioritized measurable output over thoughtful inquiry.” #EduSky #EdTech #AI the (un) shaping of understanding & (un) criticality - with constructive ideas in response. open.substack.com/pub/jeppestr...

Much of the work in #EdTech confuses specific tools and applications with general marketing hype, while ignoring connections to broader impacts of tools and the social and political narratives connected to the marketing hype. #AIEdu #EduSky

Charles Logan@charleswlogan.bsky.social · last yr.

And another question for educators and anybody pushing AI hype: if you’re welcoming AI tools and platforms into schools and universities, how are you grappling with what @ruha9.bsky.social names the New Jim Code? With the acute harm these technologies are inflicting on minoritized communities?

"[Teachers] feel guilty...as if efficiency is a moral failing." "But we must separate work that is tedious and replaceable from work that is meaningful and relational." The moral failing is not recognizing the meaningful and relational in what we cut for "efficiency". #EduSky #AIEdu #EdTech

Mindful AI for Education@mindfulaiedu.bsky.social · 2y ago

The most important thing students get in an AI-driven classroom isn’t automation—it’s you. 💡 If AI is part of your teaching, make sure your human fingerprints are all over it. #EduSky #AiEdu #EdTech New post 👉 mindfulaiedu.substack.com/p/leaving-yo...

If AI is part of your teaching, make sure your human fingerprints are all over it.

The number of edu-influencers who are taking old ideas, slapping 'AI' on them, and pretending they've found the 'golden key' to education is astounding. Often people publish books, but sometimes they want you to pay to read the second half of their blog posts. #EduSky #AIEdu

Mike Kentz@mikekentz.bsky.social · 2y ago

Want to teach #metacognition in the chat? Want to teach ethical and effective #AI use in a way that sticks? Look no further! Comparative Transcript Analysis is a classroom-tested and pedagogically sound method to achieve both! #EduSky #EduAI #AIinEducation mikekentz.substack.com/p/the-happy-...

This so exemplifies the 'solution looking for a problem' conundrum that tech is having with these new tools. They are really hoping that users will come up with viable use cases that will lead to eventual profit. #EduSky #AIEdu

Aaron Makelky@handle.invalid · 2y ago

"But what should I use AI for?" I hear this question almost daily Having a mental model of what AI should vs should not do for you is as critical as prompting or knowing tools. #aiedu #edu #edusky

“If you go to a school, it’s very much the same as 300 years ago.” <- TIL education is still dominated by one room schoolhouses, teachers will little training, and kids leaving after just a few years. Why do we take these people seriously? #EduSky #AIinEducation

DavidPBLRoss@davidpblross.bsky.social · 2y ago

Why We Need More Personalization in Education - interview with @YongZhaoEd via @techlearning www.techlearning.com/news/why-we-... #EduSky #EduSkyAI #EduCoach #TLSky #EdTech #AIinEducation #aisky #ai #artificialintelligence

The kids are alright “AI is constantly incorrect, environmentally damaging and such a stupid way of learning. I started studying so I could be taught by professionals, not a robot telling me slop gathered from hundreds of places on the internet,” www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/universit...

Outrage as university says AI tutors will run lectures in course

Three AI programs are set to replace lecture slides in a university course this semester.

nzherald.co.nz

Reflecting on how to create lessons that impact students, to inspire them to share ideas, and to support their individual needs are all ways we facilitate better connection with students. More time on software isn't. It's always efficiency over quality with these promotional posts. #AIinEducation

Courtney Garza@edtechonfire.bsky.social · 2y ago

Your Sunday reset, AI edition. Before the new week starts, use Magic School AI to: ✅ Plan engaging lessons ✅ Draft discussion questions ✅ Personalize student supports Spend less time prepping, more time connecting with students. 💡 #SmartTeaching #AIinEd #TimeWellSpent #SundayReset

Teachers are quibbling over the percentage that ChatGPT contributes to cheating behaviors, while new charters are bragging about not having teachers and the face of the 'AI' takeover of government services is saying things like this. The objectives aren't secret. #EdTech #EduSky #AIinEducation

Palmer Lucky tweet saying "What will happen in broader academia when clear scientific consensus is that AI-assisted education delivers better outcomes than 3.8M teachers currently do?"

Elon Musk quotes this tweet saying "That is already possible".
Mindful AI for Education@mindfulaiedu.bsky.social · 2y ago

This study should be an addendum to our latest post. AI doesn't cause cheating. Culture and lack of engagement do. #EduSky #AiEDU #EdTech studyfinds.org/ai-myth-debu...

Imagine dismissing communication with people about their children, tailoring lessons for your students, or deciding how you can best assess learning as 'paperwork' that should be offloaded to software. Let's advocate for better working conditions, not tech that dehumanizes our work. #EdTech #AIinEd

Courtney Garza@edtechonfire.bsky.social · 2y ago

Weekend teacher hack: Let AI draft that parent email, lesson plan, or rubric so you can actually enjoy your Saturday. ☕✨ 📌 Magic School AI = Less time on paperwork, more time for YOU. Try it today! #AIinEd #TeacherHacks #EdTech #LifeBalance

I do think people are trying their best with this, but how do we go from "AI is an umbrella phrase for systems designed to mimic human intelligence" to "AI is a tool" in a single article? It's this sort of ambiguity in terminology that makes it hard to talk about efficacy and impacts. #EduSky #AIEdu

Mica Mulloy@micamulloy.bsky.social · 2y ago

I wrote about AI myths and misconceptions for @mindfulaiedu.bsky.social this week. Check out the new post to sort fact from fiction. And an analogy to a power saw 🪚! #EduSky #EduSkyAI #AIEdu mindfulaiedu.substack.com/p/myth-vs-re...

As appealing as it may be to offload this thinking work in a time crunch, teachers should reflect on the value we bring when we (not software) decide how to prioritize feedback, create action items, etc. How much are we okay asking tech to 'speak directly to the student' for us? #EduSky #AiEdu

Mindful AI for Education@mindfulaiedu.bsky.social · 2y ago

Looking for a way to provide better feedback to students in a more timely manner? Who isn't? Try turning messy audio into streamlined, actionable feedback using AI. Details in our new post: mindfulaiedu.substack.com/p/enhancing-... #EduSky #AiEDU