Evidence Rounds

@evidencerounds.bsky.social

News you can use in hospital medicine Medical literature is doubling rapidly, but knowledge isn't. Too many studies fail to answer the questions that matter most. We find and appraise the rare practice-changing evidence and cutting edge ideas.

Two recent trials challenged the historical preference for anti-staphylococcal penicillin. For MSSA bacteremia, cefazolin should be first-line, and when the isolate is penicillin susceptible, benzylpenicillin is the preferred narrow-spectrum option

In a proof-of-concept AI second opinion study of 76 ED visits, an LLM exceeded 2 independent MD reviewers on diagnostic performance at 3 touchpoints (ER triage, ER physician & admit) Whether it outperforms physicians in real-world practice is yet to be determined

In a double-blind RCT of 108 obese AUD pts motivated for sobriety, semaglutide reduced heavy drinking days by 13% (absolute) vs placebo Reduction in drinking strongly correlated w/ weight los Suggests shared mechanism or functional unblinding, which might exaggerate benefits

Do patients on a low dose of levothyroxine truly have hypothyroidism? In a multicenter longitudinal descriptive study, 64% on a levothyroxine dose of 50 µg/d or lower were able to successfully discontinue treatment, suggesting that very low doses more often reflect overtreatment

Does hydration reduce kidney stones? A behavioral intervention ↑ fluid intake ~300 mL (w/ slight ↑ urinary symptoms) but did NOT ↓ recurrence or improve outcomes Intake difference may have been too small, as a prior small trial showed benefit w larger separation (~2.5 vs 1L)

Minocycline for acute ischemic stroke? In a multicenter RCT, oral minocycline within 72h of an ischemic stroke (NIHSS 4–25) improved functioning at 90 days (mRS 0–1: 52.6% vs 47.4%; ~5% absolute; RR 1.11), supporting a modest neuroprotective benefit

In a head-to-head trial for VTE treatment, apixaban was safer than rivaroxaban with similar effecacy at 90 days, with ~4% less clinically relevant bleeding (RR 0.5) Since the safety advantage was confined to the loading-dose phase, its not relevant for atrial fibrillation

The SOHO trial confirms the use of high-flow nasal cannula for acute hypoxic respiratory failure with less intubation (NNT ~17; benefit by day 1, plateaus by day 4) and less dyspnea (NNT ~7; ~5-point improvement on a 100-point scale)

Should longer vanc courses be prescribed for first episodes of C diff? In a Bayesian RCT, a 4-week pulse+taper reduced recurrence vs standard 2-week course at 1 month (RRR 43%, 99% probability of superiority) and at 2 mos (RRR 16%, 74% prob) But 3-month recurrence was similar

Does correcting chronic hyponatremia improve outcomes? In an RCT of hospitalized adults with Na <130, a targeted correction algorithm did not improve 30-day death/rehospitalization (20.5% vs 21.8%) or neurocognitive outcomes...

Treating addiction is hard In a pragmatic RCT of patients with nonfatal opioid overdose, ED peer navigators did not reduce 1-year outcomes This builds on a prior step-wedge cluster RCT: addiction consult increased med use, but 6-month retention was low & similar (2.4% vs 3.2%)

Mild predialysis hyperkalemia may not warrant treatment Among ESRD patients with a pre-dialysis K≥5.5, Lokelma improved long-term potassium control but did NOT reduce arrhythmia-related cardiovascular events (8.8% vs 8.9%) The trial was stopped early for low event rates

In a nationally representative sample of adults 41–76, almost all had abnormal shoulder MRI findings, including ~51% of asymptomatic individuals with partial-thickness rotator cuff tears Like spine, knee, & hip imaging, this high prevalence suggests these are normal age-related

Long-acting monthly injectable cabotegravir/rilpivirine was superior to oral ART in the LATITUDE trial among people with nonadherence, with an 18% absolute reduction in regimen failure A prior small economic analysis from a safety-net clinic suggests it is cost-effective

Up to 40% of hospitalized adults discharge to post-acute care at home or in a facility This review demystifies post-acute care with a practical framework to match the right setting to a patient’s needs and plan for a smoother transition

In an open-label RCT of HIV-related sepsis in endemic TB regions, immediate anti-TB therapy reduced 28-day mortality in the subgroup with later microbiologically confirmed tuberculosis This suggests, as with sepsis, that time to initiate anti-TB therapy might also matter

Consider single-dose amphotericin for cryptococcal meningitis In a US safety-net hospital, the AMBITION regimen established in LMICs (single-dose liposomal ampho+flucy/fluc) achieved same outcomes with fewer severe adverse events in a pre-post analysis vs standard 14-day course

Antibiotics hold up for more than half of patients with uncomplicated appendicitis, but decision to avoid upfront surgery is in the eye of the beholder At 10-year follow-up, 44% eventually underwent an appendectomy Greatest risk was in the first 12-18 months

A 2023 narrative review challenges the centrality of dual-process models, arguing that diagnostic expertise matters more Improving clinical reasoning may depend less on debiasing & more on richer problem representations, illness scripts & better access to the right knowledge

For older adults w/ newly diagnosed afib during hospitalization the 1-yr stroke risk w/o anticoag was low: 0.7% for CHA2DS2VASc 1-4 & 1.8% for 5-8 Given consensus of ≥2%/year, anticoag may be less compelling in hospital-detected AF but should still be individualized by risk

Shunting in idiopathic NPH helps gait but with notable risks In a placebo-controlled RCT of patients who improved with CSF drainage, shunting improved gait & reduced falls at 3 mos (24% vs 46%) BUT more positional headaches (NNH 3), subdural bleeds (NNH 10) & hygromas (NNH 17)

In a small but compelling proof-of-concept RCT in AUD, semaglutide reduced alcohol consumed vs placebo in a controlled setting where participants were presented with their preferred beverage Also reduced several measures of self-reported consumption Confirmatory trials needed

In a sham-controlled trial with an active control, compression garments did not significantly reduce recurrent vasovagal syncope (orthostasis excluded) But a meaningful benefit wasn't excluded (underpowered?) & fewer syncopal episodes occurred when participants actively wore it

In a pragmatic trial, RSV vaccine reduced RSV hospitalizations for respiratory illness in older adults by 83% But was rare (NNT ~1800) with similar total hospitalizations & death (numerically favored placebo) DANFLU-2 showed no benefit of high-dose vs standard influenza vax

Aspirin’s decline continues In high-risk stable CAD patients already on anticoagulation (all post-PCI, 70% with prior MI; mostly on DOACs for Afib), adding aspirin increased death, CV events, and major bleeding in a multicenter trial, prompting early termination

For provoked VTE, standard therapy is 3 months, but what about patients with ongoing risk (ie autoimmune disease, obesity)? In a single-center RCT, extended low-dose apixaban (2.5mg BID) reduced recurrent VTE vs placebo at 1 year (HR 0.13, NNT=10), with KM curves still diverging

Is GDMT for heart failure coming full circle? In a double-blind multicenter trial of advanced HFrEF, digitoxin—a safer digoxin analog not available in the US—reduced both mortality and hospitalizations A Dutch trial of digoxin is underway, with results expected soon