Matt Kirkcaldie

@matttkk.bsky.social

Obsessed with brain structure and comparative neuroanatomy. They’re not circuits. It’s not wiring. Cortex is a resonant mesh. https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3285-0168 https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Matt-Kirkcaldie [ image by https://mattcoyle.net ]

An update: huge credit to the journal editor, who when the authors resubmitted, appointed a new reviewer who took exception to the same qualities. We now have a third submission to evaluate. Authors claimed that AI tools were used to check the text for grammar and clarity, not to generate anything.

Matt Kirkcaldie@matttkk.bsky.social · 5mo ago

So – last week I had a peer review to do for a journal from a major publisher, an overview article by well published researchers. It was late, so I stayed back to work on it. Some hours in, a few things snapped into focus, and I realised that large chunks had been “written” by generative AI. (1/12)

The "is this ... a pigeon?" meme with the title Peer Review, a bookish young man regarding a butterfly tagged "Gen-AI slop", asking innocently "is this ... a scientific article?"

Meanwhile, a quote from the geniuses building our glorious new data centre in Lutruwita/Tasmania, referring to another data centre they’d like to quickly whip up here while they’re at it. At least genuinely seems like a mistake: who’d voluntarily explain how dodgy their plan is? #politas #auspol

"We will likely use Tas Irrigation, but we do not want to highlight this yet, as they are yet to agree to supply us, as we fall outside their normal customer base [agriculture] and they need legal approval to supply us.

Everybody in the "climate space" (which means everyone on earth...) needs to understand these mind-blowing figures. Google's "total electricity consumption jumped from 31 terawatt hours (TWh) in 2024 to 43 TWh in 2025." In ONE year. The AI corporate arms race is eating the world.

Ketan Joshi@ketanjoshi.co · last mo.

NEW BLOG FOR YOU Google's energy consumption numbers in their new climate report are mind-blowing. 2 years ago they flipped from linear to exponential growth, and their climate impact is blowing out, too. A WILD testament to the obscene bloat and waste of GenAI: ketanjoshi.co/2026/07/01/g...

a chart showing google's rising energy consumption - huge, and rising faster than ever before

Insightful analysis by @hey.paris on another Tasmanian government capitulation to outside commercial interests without considering consequences. Rockliff's government are such easy marks, I wonder if the word is getting around. Perhaps @tasinquirer.bsky.social should take a look.

Dr Paris Buttfield-Addison@hey.paris · last mo.

I got very mad about all the #AI data centres that are planned in #Tasmania. hey.paris/posts/ai-dat... #ai #ml #politas #auspol

hmmm ... they quoted me in this article, saying some meaningless enthusiastic stuff (some of which I'm not sure i said?) but they sure dropped the main points i was trying to make, which can be found in this thread: bsky.app/profile/kenm...

The Transmitter @thetransmitter.bsky.social · last mo.

HHMI’s Janelia Research Campus will close two of its programs dedicated to rodent work, @thetransmitter.bsky.social has learned. #neuroskyence By @callimcflurry.bsky.social www.thetransmitter.org/community/ex...

When utilized in literature review, LLMs consistently 1. fail to mention female authors in female-led literatures, 2. insist that men are more influential or more heavily cited when this is contradicted by objective citation counts, and 3. attribute women’s work to hallucinated male scholars.

Yesterday Murdoch's Adelaide Advertiser printed a despicable ZERO IMMIGRATION UAP advertisement on the same page as story celebrating Adelaide local Nestory Irankunda's world cup goal. Nestory and his family came to Australia as refugees. News Corp owe the Irankunda family an apology. So offensive.

Bild

Bizarre developments at @frontiersin.bsky.social, somehow worse than any imaginable outcome of acquisition by @springernature.com. Ironically the Frontiers account's pinned post is "Behind every article is an author, reviewer, and editor who chose to uphold the highest of standards."

Michael Okun@michael-okun.bsky.social · 2mo ago

I’ve officially resigned as Associate Editor for Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience. It used to be a reputable journal, but became a case study in how forced automation destroys academic integrity. 👇