During a creative writing class, another student wrote “NO SUPERNATURAL ELEMENTS!” on page one and a giant “NO” in red marker on every page of the story. No other feedback. The assignment was to write a story about a headline from World Weekly News. Mine was “My Husband Became a Zombie.”
If you see this, please tell me the worst/most baffling bit of creative feedback you've ever recieved. Mine is still the time somebody told me my aliens had names that were too alien. Not that they were unpronounceable, just that they didn't sound enough like human names.