Fraser McNair

@ralphtorta.bsky.social

Medievalist, blogger, charter enthusiast. Currently working as a research fellow on the Music In The Shadows project at the University of Nottingham. Read my blog at: https://salutemmundo.wordpress.com/

Rosamond McKitterick, my doctoral supervisor, has died. It is deeply unfair that someone so healthy should have been taken before her due time. But although I am sad, it is heartening to to think not just about the legacy left by her body of work...

OK, don't know how this is going to sound, but I promise it's because I'm basic, not egotistical: I am doing a first re-read of the initial draft of a major chunk of my book, and I keep getting distracted, not because my prose is so inspiring or anything, but because c10th history is so interesting!

Y'know what'd be useful? (And might exist, IDK) A list of lay authors of the earlier Middle Ages. Said b/c I'm rn comparing Fulk le Réchin and William IX (so right at the end of the earlier MA admittedly) and thought 'hang on, two lay rulers writing within decades of each other? That's weird!'

More progress on this. Thanks to @graemeyward.bsky.social, I've been able to see BNF Moreau 16, the charter of 996 with Bishop Fredelo in it. And the dating clause is pretty unambiguous! The charter is dated "the year when King Robert of the Franks began to rule in Francia".

Fraser McNair@ralphtorta.bsky.social · 6mo ago

Today's mystery is the anti-bishop of Elne. Elne is a see on the Spanish March, and in 994, its bishop, Fredelo, showed up at the Council of Saint-Paulien hosted by Bishop Guy of Le Puy. salutemmundo.wordpress.com/2024/04/16/c... Only problem is, at the time he wasn't bishop of Elne.

Annoyed again at Bernard Bachrach. No, William of Malmesbury did not describe Fulk Nerra performing a _calcatio colli_ Bachrach: Fulk *places foot on neck* "now art thou vanquished" What William actually says: Fulk, kicking the shit out of his son, "bet you're beaten now, boy, huh? huh?'

So I've noticed that Post-Carolingian (West Frankish*) authors will present groups of subjects of non-royal rulers as having capacity for autonomous action (e.g. "the English rebelled" as opposed to "a bunch of people rebelled") when they can be seen in terms of ethnic identities...

After the last couple of days of mysteries, here's one I cleared up recently. A couple of years ago, I posted about a notice from Saint-Martin in Tours. In this notice, Count Fulk of Anjou invaded Saint-Martin, in response to which the canons humiliated their relics...

Here's something odd. Count Geoffrey Martel of Anjou (r. 1040-1060) founded two major abbeys, Sainte-Trinité in Vendôme (1040) and Notre-Dame in Saintes (1047). It's generally recognised that the foundation documents of both these institutions are closely textually...

Pleased to announce my latest article is in print, courtesy of the fine people at _Reading Medieval Studies_! It's an analysis of two of the canonical texts from the time of Hugh Capet's accession, and why they are not all that they seem... salutemmundo.wordpress.com/2025/12/20/n...

Name in Print XVIII

Some articles are not written from the most noble of motives. When dealing with the accession of the Capetians, there are a few old chestnuts which, simply, get on my nerves. I have already complai…

salutemmundo.wordpress.com