Rob Horning

@robhorning.bsky.social

robhorning.substack.com

One of the really difficult lessons of the last 100 years is that convenience - drawing on mass market capabilities to do things faster - is isolating and individualising. We become one in relation to the market rather than one in relation to other people. GenAI is the peak expression of that.

Anthony Moser@anthonymoser.com · last mo.

strong parallels to how we were told to make individually responsible risk assessments around COVID at the same time any useful sources of information were systematically dismantled

the "Eliza effect" is reminiscent of role-playing games— software providing a structure for an emotional attachment to a simulation, more or less for its own sake. LLMs/chatbots make more sense as gaming engines than as "intelligence"

Matt Pearce@mattdpearce.com · 2mo ago

TIL people were getting duped by the humanness of chatbots as early as the 1960s. AI psychosis was old before it was new! We haven’t learned anything. mattdpearce.substack.com/p/what-we-ca...

ELIZA could hold basic "conversations," including playing the role of a psychotherapist with real human users. An example of ELIZA's responses to one woman are shown in capital letters:

Men are all alike.
IN WHAT WAY
They're always bugging us about something or other.
CAN YOU THINK OF A SPECIFIC EXAMPLE
Well, my boyfriend made me come here.
YOUR BOYFRIEND MADE YOU COME HERE
He says I'm depressed much of the time.
I AM SORRY TO HEAR YOU ARE DEPRESSED

Excerpt from Joseph Weizenbaum's 1976 book "Computer Power and Human Reason: From Judgment to
Calculation."

Think “slop” is part of the long-standing project of producing consumers who can’t experience satisfaction—no contentment, just more content

Roland Meyer@bildoperationen.bsky.social · 2mo ago

#Slop matters. But hardly for the reason this sloppy paper (which needed no less than nine authors) claims: «[P]eople want more content than humans can supply.» Really? No. Platforms want more content than humans can supply, and now machines can produce much more content than people actually want.

We often desire the symbol more than what it represents: people go into debt because a new car makes them feel like they’ve “made it.” Generated text is a symbol of text in this sense, a cognitive debt that allows people to “think they have thought” about it when they have moved away from thinking.

The most important upcoming scholarly work on AI isn't going to be on how processes become automated, but how subjects (we) begin to lose autonomy, and reflect the regressions of automation in our habits and thought.

from Sigfried Kracauer's "Totalitarian Propaganda": propaganda usually seen as being in service of some other aim, but ultimately it becomes an end in itself, a manifestation of power for its own sake

National Socialist agitators do not entice with intellectual proofs and arguments,
but rather seduce with the “primordial energy of rhythm.”46 In fact,
rhythmic formations gain the upper hand as, and to the extent that, the swarm
of previous promises loses its value. Shocks are orchestrated in random material
to prevent any respite from the tension; waves of propaganda are sent out and, as
required, either build steadily or swiftly ebb away; and, in all cases, care is taken
to coordinate tempi to good effect. These occurrences are lent propagandist significance
by the rhythmic quality of the course they take: the skillful sequencing
of quiet and action, of push and pull. If the proclamation of content, of substantive
and attractive goals, was once decisive, now the appeal to the psycho- physical
state associated with the pseudo- reality is predominantly through form— the
form in which the propaganda accomplishes the requisite acts and resolutions.
The further this process advances, the more the nihilism with which the propaganda
handles all convictions reveals itself, of course, and the more undisguised
is the eruption of the will to power, whose product is propaganda. Still, the “primordial
energy of rhythm” could hardly provide lasting compensation for the
destruction of the contents of propaganda if the propaganda didn’t also succeed
in making people forget about its own vacuity by stamping the now transparent
will to power as the content itself

felt like this too neatly linked the feeling of fakeness to the recent pivot to short form video. all metricized and algorithmic media is deceptive. like, what's the "real" way to post content in a system that links attention to profit?

Bild

clips are like AI summaries in that they seem to promise a way to master content overload, but achieve this by making people passive consumers of an ever more superficial stream of disconnected fragments

memes are like fashion trends that people "wear" in media by posting; decoding "what they mean" beyond that verges on folly, like asking what different skirt lengths "really mean"