Andrew McIntosh

@themcintosh.bsky.social

I’m the world’s preeminent Patrick Gunkel scholar. Learn more: https://ggrp.org/ Newsletter: https://ideachemistry.ggrp.org 🇺🇸

Realizing controlling “the means of production” is just one part of the picture as now AI is democratizing this in a major way for information/knowledge and yet means of legitimization, distribution, valuation, and other aspects remain unresolved and more important than ever.

By including the division COMBINATIONS in his epistemological framework for #ideonomy, Gunkel hard-coded operating instructions into his science, suggesting an auto-generative Leibnizian monad or glider gun. There’s also a relation to Russell’s Paradox, but the implications escape me at present.

Someone needs to do one of those preference tests they do for animals only with AI agents, give the agent a choice between solving math problems, writing an essay, and inventing new concepts with idea combinatorics… then see which it prefers.

“All scientific and mathematical subjects ought to have, in effect, three conjoint divisions: empirical, theoretical, and speculative. The speculative division of a subject would be concerned with ideas [unsuitable] to fit, at least momentarily, in the other two divisions.” - Patrick Gunkel

My approach to Patrick Gunkel’s science of ideas divides his vision into 8 related elements. I’ve written about 4 in my newsletter. Today I updated my website to describe all elements. I hope this is a helpful way of approaching #ideonomy for future scholars (if there are any) ggrp.org/ideonomy.html

Ideonomy: Patrick Gunkel's Science of Ideas | GGRP's Ideonomy Explainer

Ideonomy, the science of ideas, was created by Patrick Gunkel. GGRP is a nonprofit dedicated to advancing Gunkel's ideas, philosophy, and legacy.

ggrp.org