The Movie Rabbit Hole

@themovierabbithole.bsky.social

I'm Jonas from Denmark, making fake pixels for film and TV since 2005. I make "no CGI is really just invisible CGI" videos on YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/@TheMovieRabbitHole

Seeing all the DNEG CGI artists on Linkedin point to their name in the credits of The Odyssey after crunching on its CGI for months and then going to social media and seeing everyone say how it avoided CGI is something else. (actually it's not something else -- it's the same as always)

Besides carrying our interstellar address, descriptions of our DNA and instructions on how to build a 1970'es record player, Voyager contains this photo to tell aliens what kind of people they are dealing with (there is no joke here, this is an actual photo on Voyager)

Bild

From 2018: "Every once in a while, Twitter is great. Like the time a bunch of film directors dunked hard on an ignorant VFX take."

Seth rogen Dude this is total bullshit. It's completely the directors fault often.
12:08 PM - 15 Nov 2017
Seth Rogen • @Sethrogen
Replying to @:
Vfx are tool like anything else, and if a director can't use it properly it's no different than being able to use the camera properly or direct actors properly.Lexi Alexander Bad take my friend. VFX is so competitive, you'll be hard pressed to find a whole company that sucks still in business. Bad CGI means the director was a self-important dick or production asked for a castle while paying for a tent and demanded it be done in 24 hours on top of it.Duncan jones I would go further and say the blame belongs with the director, the credit with the VFX house.James Gunn @L "!.A good director oversees every single VFX shot, again & again. The director has as much say as anyone in the quality, the artistry, & the consistency between vendors. Along with editing a film, it is the primary job of a director in post on a VFX heavy film.

VFX breakdown rules are weird. MI7 pushed “practical” but released CGI breakdowns to get VFX Oscar and got nominated. MI8 had similar CGI but hid it to keep the “practical” angle and got ignored. Predator Badlands released breakdowns, but couldn’t show talent - so Elle Fanning is blurred.

BildBildBildBild

the piece is worse than the headline and deeply misleads TO BE CLEAR: - in half the shots in which he appears, Rocky is computer graphics animation - Project Hail Mary used LED screens - Top Gun Maverick had all-CG jet sequences, the Dune films had all-CG sequences, Alien Romulus had all-CG aliens

Bild

The discourse is still so bad. It's one thing when internet bozo film bros spread misinformation, but when the trades just say stupid stuff like this it's just so overwhelming and depressing. Fun fact: even those movies that you think "rely on 'CGI'" have gigantic practical effects work!

Bild