I also think a lot of this problem comes from the fact that most games that are widely reviewed are pretty competent. Games like Mindseye sometimes get a lot of attention relative to how much actual anticipation there is and ultimately only serve to remind people there's a low end of the scale.
games need to earn their scores - 8 means Great and that is EARNED. we have a whole spectrum of numbers to use, we can’t be going “uhh it’s aight, 8/10” like cmon man