Zach Dorfman

@zachsdorfman.bsky.social

National Security Reporter. Features in Politico, Rolling Stone, Wired, Foreign Policy. Working on a book on the history of deep cover for Penguin-Random House. It’s always Berlin 1989 somewhere. Email: thebrushpass1@protonmail.com

MacArthur, in addition to beinng anti-democratic, also left a lot to be be desired as a military commander. I don't think Halberstam talked about this is in the book, but he had 9 hours warning after Pearl Harbor that a Japanese attack on the Philippines was imminent and did nothing.

Continuing my Korean War/Halberstam posting: It’s hard to convey how malignant Douglas MacArthur was, how anti-democratic, what a persistent threat to civil-military relations. Conversely, George Marshall was a man of towering integrity and wisdom.

One thing that Halberstam does brilliantly in “The Coldest Winter” is linking red-baiting (“who ‘lost’ China?”) and the growing political power the pro-Nationalist China Lobby to the decimation of the State Deor’s East Asianists, causing decades of distorted foreign policy through the Vietnam War.

Found two separate declassifications of the same document from 1949, with different redactions. Ridiculous that anything from that far back ahould be censored, but a side-by-side comparison shows the redactions in the more blacked-out version to be overwhelmingly banal.

Declass 9/11 documents are incredible: "DoD is an 'avaricious shark' and tries to grab everything it can," said former Senator Warren Rudman. "DCI Tenet is very frustrated by it but will not say so publicly. The 'giant sucking sound' is the sound of DoD 'slurping up IC functions,'" said Rudman."