Amanda Weiss

@amandaweiss.bsky.social

Assistant Professor, Cornell Department of Government. Political methodology, causal inference, ethics, and criminal justice policy. www.amandakweiss.com Opinions my own, reposts not (necessarily) endorsements, etc.

I am from Indiana, which has a lot of deer. Upstate NY deer are on a whole different level. I was walking the dog and we saw a deer. The dog started barking at the deer. And the deer CAME CLOSER. I think it was ENTERTAINED. And, sure, the dog is not very scary. But the deer is a WILD ANIMAL.

Ofc I say this and personally put WAY too much effort into reviews. And then I die inside when my papers spend six months under review or get torpedoed because someone was not on board with my type of paper existing or are evaluated by someone who doesn't know how math works. So there's that...

Amanda Weiss@amandaweiss.bsky.social · 2w ago

But that's not my only concern. A big issue with AI reviews IMO — hot take 🚨, maybe big Assistant Professor Energy — is that reviewing is good for reviewers. Like it's good to see new scholarship and know what is being submitted in your field! And good to keep sharp by doing constructive critique!

Also I'm SO PUMPED to be a non-presenting coauthor. 🙏 I like the sound of my voice as much as the next academic, but I did 5 conference presentations on other papers earlier this summer and I am now in my couch potato era. Until APSA.

Amanda Weiss@amandaweiss.bsky.social · last mo.

I'm so proud of this paper that @nottone.bsky.social and I did on prisons... massive data collection! the political economy of criminal legal system! jackknife standard errors!

Y'ALL I was reading up on the history of the Kitagawa-Oaxaca-Blinder decomposition, which is already wild. Then I discovered that THIS is how young Evelyn became Mrs. Kitagawa (even before becoming Dr. Kitagawa).

Wikipedia screenshot of a biography of Evelyn Kitagawa, which reads: "She was born as Evelyn Mae Rose, in 1920[4] in Hanford, California, to a family of Portuguese Catholic descent. After earning a bachelor's degree in mathematics from the University of California, Berkeley in 1941, she began working for the War Relocation Authority, which ran the internment camps of Japanese-Americans during World War II, as head of its statistics unit. In one of the camps, she met her future husband, Joseph Mitsuo Kitagawa, who had come to the US in 1941 as a divinity student and became an Episcopalian minister while interned. After marrying him, her family disowned her and she lost contact with them."

I made an over-engineered Qualtrics survey to handle my wedding RSVPs (name look-up, custom font packs, etc.) Now I'm like, Should I think of a survey experiment to run on family and friends?!

Screenshot of a Qualtrics survey collecting RSVPs for a wedding.

I just found out, via reviewer request, about AJPS' new submissions stream for reanalyses. I'm intrigued. Philosophers have written about creating groups of dedicated replication scientists (see, e.g., work by Felipe Romero) and I've wondered about how that model would work in poli sci.

Screenshot of a post from the American Journal of Political Science Editors-in-Chief, reading: "This post describes new policies at AJPS regarding Correspondence and Corrections.

Maintaining an accurate scholarly record is one of the most important responsibilities of a journal. When findings published in AJPS contain significant errors, the discipline is best served when those errors are identified, evaluated, and addressed publicly.

Until now, AJPS has not had a dedicated channel for publishing critical reanalyses by scholars other than the original authors. We are introducing one.

AJPS will now publish short critical essays called “Correspondence” in which scholars who are not the original authors challenge the central claims of a previously published AJPS"

i've decided not to listen to the audio of a teacher reporting a kindergartender because frankly I don't want to become the person that that event would turn me into. but one thing I hope we are collectively coming to grips with is what it meant that we have lived among such people this whole time

Drew Harwell@drewharwell.com · 7mo ago

New: A comedian set up a fake ICE tip line as a joke. Then 100 calls flooded in: neighbors ratting on neighbors, a teacher reporting a kindergartener. Fans say the viral TikToks revealed deportation's "banality of evil." Conservatives say he should be in prison wapo.st/4kM4qbF

It seems like an expression of privilege, naivete, or inhumanity to say that COVID mitigation was not worth it. Lockdowns have consequences and implementation sucked. I'm teaching that generation now. But also - more than 1 million Americans died.

Mark Copelovitch@mcopelov.bsky.social · 9mo ago

Oh. This is deeply depressing & incredibly ugly about what it says you can get away with if you have the right elite private university on your academic business card. I thought we were done with this, on this issue, with Emily Oster. Sigh.

Ahem. Political science is the *best* science. In all seriousness: Political scientists use the scientific method. And it's not like the political world is mystical/made-up. Assuming a closed physical universe, human behavior has some explanation - it's just hard to identify.* *In all senses

Post nicht verfügbar.

I just learned that Cornell Govt grad students will lead a jeopardy game, featuring faculty trivia, at the end-of-semester party. Learning this is how I also learned that Yale Poli Sci was probably unusual for having a student-written skit full-on *roasting* faculty at the department party...