Books of All Time

@booksofalltime.bsky.social

A new podcast that's tackling classic literature in chronological order. New episodes every other Sunday. Hosted by @rosejudson.bsky.social.

THE ODYSSEY By Elon Musk EMIT A RESULT, GROK, OF THE BIOHACKING ABSOLUTELY GOATED ONION-LAYERED CRYPTO DADDY HE WAS SUPER VERY GOOD RAD AT EVERYTHING, HOW HE SELF-DRIVING CYBERTRUCKED A.F. TO ITHACA AFTER BUSTING UNIONS AND DEFYING TAX LAWS IN TROY MANY NPCS HE OUTSHINED, HELLA SKILLED AT GAMING

Here at BoAT, we only nurtured one major hope for Nolan's adaptation: namely, that Robert Pattinson would be an entertaining slimeball as Antinous. No less an authority than Emily Wilson says he is, so we look forward to seeing it!

EMILY WILSON@emilyrcwilson.bsky.social · 2w ago

I wrote about the Nolan Odyssey for the LRB. I'll summarize some of my main points below, in case you don't feel like reading all that. www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v4...

We can heartily recommend this volume, having relied on it for last year's Big Fat Greek Drama Summer. Some of the essays at the back about the origins of drama and what's known about how plays in Ancient Athens were staged were also really illuminating!

Benjamin Dreyer@bcdreyer.social · 2w ago

BTW, ever faithful to the home team, I recommend to you this Modern Library volume, which includes wonderful translations by, among other distinguished contributors, @emilyrcwilson.bsky.social.

The Greek Plays, from the Modern Library.

5. Adaptations are often most successful when they make clear, courageous choices about what to leave out - so, for instance, the movie "The Return" seems to me both a much more radical departure from the original source, and also a more successful film.

There is a lot to say about the Nolan Odyssey movie. But one point that I think has not been emphasized enough is: this is a film about living in LA, as Nolan, my erstwhile British compatriot and age mate, has done for years. I gather it’s a strange place.

We only spent about six months with the Indian epics, but yes: Homer is a master of brevity compared to them, even when comparing the heavily abridged English versions available to the average reader. Hanuman is THE BEST, though.

Audrey Truschke@audreytruschke.bsky.social · 3w ago

I have spent the last 3 days binge-reading Emily Wilson's Odyssey. After two decades with my mind occupied by the Indian epics, I have a lot of reactions (including, damn, the Odyssey is short). I'm enamored with the translation though.

I have spent the last 3 days binge-reading Emily Wilson's Odyssey. After two decades with my mind occupied by the Indian epics, I have a lot of reactions (including, damn, the Odyssey is short). I'm enamored with the translation though.

Bild

The events of the Odyssey would have been set 500 years previously at the time that Homer composed them, equivalent to writing about the voyages of Columbus today. For example Homer probably imagined Iron Age hoplite armor, while actual Bronze Age Mycenean armor looked like this:

Volunteer marine soldiers in simulated combat wearing the Dendra armour replica during the empirical study (right) and an artistic photo shoot (left). Photo credit: Andreas Flouris and Marija Marković. Permission required for reproduction.

"The glory is the actual fantasy. Most men in classical antiquity weren’t noble warriors. . . . They told tales of outsized heroes they could never equal, just like we do now. What was attainable was a family and a home. Those are the things that are slipping away. Achilles was never real."

Michael Hobbes@michaelhobbes.bsky.social · 3w ago

"No moral panic is more unoriginal than the fear that contemporary men are no longer as manly as the heroes who preceded them."

Just going to say here, I think I've said this before, a 'historically accurate' version of the Odyssey is not possible because the Odyssey does not take place in a historical setting - it takes place in a fantastical pastiche of four centuries, mixed in with gods and monsters.

Watcher Guru@watcher.guru · 3w ago

JUST IN: Elon Musk says Grok will make a "full-length movie" of The Odyssey that is "historically accurate" by the end of this year.

Like, you could attempt a historically grounded depiction of what a siege or large-scale raid in 1184 BC might have looked like, but that's not the Odyssey. You could attempt a historically grounded depiction of what a sea voyage c. 750 BC might look like, but that's not the Odyssey either.