Eric Segall

@espinsegall.bsky.social

#Notacourt but yes a law prof

I see 4 major developments manifest in yesterday's elections: 1) El-Sayed's victory, along with multiple downballot victories shows a significant expansion of DSA/Sanders/AOC-aligned power in the heartland, where we've been told it just couldn't reach. 1/5

“Constitutional law changes substantially in this country when the justices’ politics and values change, and often for no other reason. The Supreme Court has never been an institution that puts law in any form above the justices' aggregate policy preferences.” www.dorfonlaw.org/2026/08/prec...

Precedent and Personnel: When the Justices Change so Does the Constitution

Readers of this blog know that I am a harsh critic of the Roberts Court (to say the least). The current GOP justices have dramatically alter...

dorfonlaw.org

M

The "and that's why Trump won" style of statement is worse than monocausal oversimplification. It's just wrong. On the blog, Prof Neil Buchanan explains how even Trump critics neglect or forget fact that Trump as president was an unlikely accident of history (as was the Reagan presidency, BTW). 👇

We Must Not Forget that Trump <i>and Reagan</i> Both Became President by Accident

I should state up front that this column can be added to the "failing to remember history, doomed to repeat it" file.  There is nothing new,...

dorfonlaw.org

M

Trump v Slaughter was wrong on its own terms. In an essay on Balkinization, Prof Jeff Gordon argues it also failed to account for changes in accountability worked by the 22nd Am. On my blog, I evaluate his argument and place it in context of other shifts beyond an amendment's particular focus. 👇

The 22nd Amendment and Other Missing Parts of the Roberts Court's Constitutional Vision

As I noted here on the blog last week, I'll be spending the day tomorrow with lawyers, a judge, a journalist, and several other law profess...

dorfonlaw.org

I worked for New York’s largest medical center at the start of the pandemic. There were morgue trucks on the streets. They set up emergency medical tents in Central Park. Healthcare worker colleagues died. It is horrific that RFK Jr is on national TV lying that ICUs were empty.

So many sneering elitist journalists with snarky posts over the past months that the Reflecting Pool story was trivial. It was so trivial that the DC US Attny presented false evidence to a grand jury to indict an innocent man to please the President while they both lied about it.

M

After Dr. Fauci took the Fifth, the Florida AG tweeted a threat to investigate. That can't have been a basis for Fauci's fear of prosecution before the tweet but it sheds light on prior red-state AGs' threats. Thus, I reassess whether fear of state prosecution justified Fauci in taking the Fifth. 👇

Fauci Fifth Follow-up

Yesterday on this blog I discussed Dr. Anthony Fauci's invocation of his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination when testifying b...

dorfonlaw.org

DOJ asked the 5th Circuit to save it from being "crushed" by a "flood" of habeas cases now, im just a simple legal writer, but I suspect DOJ wouldnt have to deal with so many unconstitutional detention lawsuits if it didnt unconstitutionally detain so many people ballsandstrikes.org/law-politics...

District Court Judges Are Unimpressed By the Fifth Circuit’s “Precedential Stay” Stunt

At the White House’s request, America’s Trumpiest appeals court attempts to issue an order that does not exist.

ballsandstrikes.org

M

Dr. Anthony Fauci was right that Rand Paul and other Republicans are out to get him, but in light of his pardon and case law rejecting "anticipatory perjury" as a basis for fearing prosecution, his invocation of his 5th Am right against self-incrimination was legally dubious. Details on the blog. 👇

Was Dr. Fauci Entitled to Invoke the Fifth Amendment?

In response to a subpoena, yesterday, Dr. Anthony Fauci appeared before the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs. ...

dorfonlaw.org

Maybe the American people are beginning to realize that the Supreme Court is not a court, as @espinsegall.bsky.social has long maintained, but is instead a fundamentally political institution. And, under John Roberts' leadership as chief justice, it has become an overtly partisan agent of the GOP.

Eric Segall@espinsegall.bsky.social · 7d ago

“Never in a Gallup poll has the Supreme Court’s approval rating hit such a low point.” #notacourt www.newsweek.com/supreme-cour...

Here is a full list of every state that DOJ had sued and lost for access to their voter file: Arizona California Connecticut Kentucky Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island Virginia West Virginia Wisconsin

M

On the blog, Prof Neil Buchanan celebrates an 11th Circuit ruling invalidating Florida's Stop WOKE Act's application to state universities but cautions that Republicans in Florida and elsewhere are hardly done attacking academic freedom and higher education more broadly. 👇

Is It Safe for Professors to Go Back to Florida? (Spoiler Alert: No. No, it is not.)

Earlier this month, a divided panel of the Eleventh Circuit surprised many people -- most definitely including me -- with a ruling that Flor...

dorfonlaw.org