Guy Hamilton-Smith

@guyhamiltonsmith.com

Civil rights & criminal defense attorney. Amateur Giles Corey impressionist. Views expressed are mine, but they could be yours for a low low price.

I think people debating about whether Holmes was lying or not are missing the point about you can see everything. It's really a much more interesting (and unsettling) film than the Holmes documentary costume it's wearing

A reminder on Indigenous Peoples' Day: Native people are incarcerated in state and federal prisons at more than 4x the rate of white people. This is the direct result of centuries of oppression and theft from Native people.

It occurs to me that the tendency towards medicalizing executions is not for the benefit of the person being executed. It's for us -- to give it an appearance of being humane, even as it makes it far less so. It's so we don't have to be made uncomfortable by the sight of our own lust for blood.

I think two things can be true simultaneously: a patronage system for pardons is grotesque, and the traditional model of only granting handfuls of clemency requests in the safest political cases is *also* grotesque.

Not for nothing, but I think it's pretty horrific that the state can just continue to re-roll juries until they get a conviction or an acquittal. Also, I have a big defense attorney crush on Kevin Reddington.

I cannot stress enough that there is no language in the First Step Act that suggests Congress intended such a parsimonious reading of compassionate release; indeed, there is language that suggests the exact opposite. One major goal was to expand compassionate release. So why is SCOTUS shrinking it?

I read a whole article about Daniel Cameron and where'd his political career take a wrong turn and not one word about him sandbagging the grand jury in Breonna Taylor's case and lying about it to the press (which we only know about because the grand jurors lawyered up to talk about it). Weird.

I have a client I did a habeas for. I believe he was convicted of a crime it was not possible for him to have committed, and the government knew that because evidence they had (but did not introduce) proves it. He's autistic, with the social-emotional functioning of a young child.

I wrote, I think, the best thing I’ve ever written yesterday. It just happened to be filed in federal court, and in support of a client and an issue I’d stick my neck out for. Also, I got to use “transmogrification” in a brief, which, believe it or not, was the right word to use.

I think the thing people miss when someone with resources gets acquitted or a conviction reversed is that it happens because the government cuts corners. It takes resources to find out where they cut them. Don’t be upset that someone found them, be upset that they were cut in the first place.

Chief Justice Roberts says the court isn't political. This week, six justices "read" 107 pages of legal briefing in 38 minutes and let Alabama gerrymander its congressional map mid-election. The stopwatch says otherwise.

I ran into my old boss yesterday, and he told me he was very proud of me, and that a lot of people would have given up, but I didn’t. I reminded him that there were many times when I wanted to, but I had people who told me to get up and keep moving forward. Including, and especially, him.