Jocelyn Downie

@jgdownie.bsky.social

Professor Emeritus, Faculties of Law and Medicine, Dalhousie University. Working on assisted dying, sport integrity, photography, and woodturning.

I've opened an extremely private medical procedure to researchers and the press. I could say it's because I want to make this more transparent for people. I could say it's because I want the government to face the absurdity of the situation. How much of that is just justification, I'll never know.

Much of Tucker Carlson’s two-hour interview with Kelsi Sheren was devoted to repeating the same misleading claims about MAiD that we have heard many times before. However, a few notably different claims caught our attention—and we thought they warranted a closer look.

This Week (or so) in MAiD Misinformation - The Tucker Carlson Edition

This week in MAiD misinformation is dedicated to Tucker Carlson, who interviewed a familiar Canadian purveyor of misinformation and conspiracy theories about MAiD.

maidincanada.substack.com

A false claim can be made in seconds. Correcting it may take months. Mr. Friesen of the EPC claimed that the American Association of Suicidology denied any distinction between MAiD and suicide. Six months later, the AAS republished a statement saying precisely the opposite, and more. Our latest:

How One False Claim Took Six Months to Correct

The American Association of Suicidology republishes its statement distinguishing MAiD from suicide—and illustrates one of the greatest challenges of combating misinformation.

maidincanada.substack.com

BC's Mental Health Act violates Charter rights (sections 7 and 15), court finds: You can't assume an involuntarily hospitalized person lacks capacity to consent or withhold consent to treatment. Win for disability rights activists: www.bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/sc/2... ht @ivacheung.com

2026 BCSC 1416 Council of Canadians with Disabilities v. British Columbia (Attorney General)

Council of Canadians with Disabilities v. British Columbia (Attorney General),

bccourts.ca

📱Your DMs can be a space for manipulation. Know the signs. Sport Integrity Canada's video breaks down what national-level athletes need to know about staying safe online. 🔵 How to recognize manipulation in your messages 🟠 Steps you can take if something feels off 🔵 Where to get support

I hope she does consider the report because then she will see that the "Supplemental Opinion of the Liberal Party of Canada" suggested that MAiD for persons with sole mental illness is not necessary because they have options - buy fentanyl on the street and overdose. Shocking but true.

André Picard @picardonhealth @picardonhealth.bsky.social · 4w ago

Attorney-General’s lawyer asks court to consider parliamentary report on MAID for mental illness in case of 49-year-old woman seeking “emergency relief” to end her life, by @kkirkup.bsky.social www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/artic... via @theglobeandmail.com

Can a handful of deliberately selected, unusually complex MAiD cases tell us whether Canada's entire MAiD system is failing? That's the question at the centre of an exchange in BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care. With permission, we republish Dr. Konia Trouton and colleagues' response.

Ontario’s MAiD Death Review Committee- avoiding misunderstandings

Committee members respond to Ramona Coelho, David Shannon, and Trudo Lemmens

maidincanada.substack.com

E. Jean Carroll spent nearly a decade in court fighting one of the most powerful men in the world. She fought with tenacity and grace — and she won. She is one of my personal heroes. We all owe her a debt of gratitude.

"'MAiD access for patients with mental illness will be a government decision,' Carney says." So decision will be to tell them no access to MAiD - instead they can die by suicide by using illegal narcotics like fentanyl??? That's what the "Supplemental Opinion of the Liberal Party of Canada" says...

These are the voices the Parliamentary Committee majority refused to hear before making their recommendation to "indefinitely exclude" them from access to MAiD (and breach their Charter rights). Holding out faint hope the Government will do due diligence before making decision on MAiD MI-SUMC.

Canadians with mental illness who saw MAID as an option feel abandoned: 'They've left me with nothing'

TORONTO - Betrayed. Dehumanized. Devastated.

thecanadianpressnews.ca

The Globe and Mail published our letter in response to Dr. Coelho calling for the government to further restrict and regulate MAiD. (The full text of our letter is reproduced at the end of our post.) The Globe limits letters to 150 words. Here, we expanded on the reasoning behind our response.

Medical Ethics Should Not Disappear When MAiD Is Involved

The Globe and Mail published our letter responding to Dr. Ramona Coelho’s piece calling for the government to take further steps to restrict and regulate MAiD.

maidincanada.substack.com

In its continuing campaign against 🇨🇦Canada’s enlightened MAID legislation, @TheGlobeandMail.com runs another screed from an anti zealot, the entire subtext of which is “stiff upper lip, bucko, keep on suffering intolerably or commit suicide if you like. The choice rejected by the SCC in 2015. 🤷🏼🙄🤷🏼

Bild

Carney: “There’s a report, after much deliberation and many testimonies. So, I think it’s significant. But this isn’t a personal matter; it’s a matter of the rights of Canadians, and the medical evidence and expert advice. So, we’ll make a decision, but it seems to me the direction is clear,”

'Direction is clear' on MAID, Carney says, after report recommends against expansion

Prime Minister Mark Carney says the decision on whether to expand eligibility for assisted dying is not a "personal matter.

nationalpost.com