Leander Goldbach

@lgoldbach.bsky.social

Ph.D. student @ Wagner Lab - University of Zürich

AI is not "threatening" higher education but exposing that we have largely replaced student-teacher relationships with an anonymous conveyer belt of conveniently assessable performance metrics. We need to talk to students instead of fueling an arms race between AI generation and AI detection.

"... the most immediate risk [of AI] is 'mediocrity at scale,' a flood of work that isn’t wrong enough to dismiss but isn’t interesting enough to advance anything." Akin to what PhD students have to produce to meet arbitrary degree requirements. Both the result of Goodhart's law. shorturl.at/S3vln

It’s time to get rid of the peer-reviewed paper

The peer-reviewed journal article, perhaps the single most important device behind the expansion of scientific knowledge in the last century, is an extraordinarily expensive way to share novelty: e…

pardoguerra.org

Very similar results had been obtained by Cernan, Harrison and Schmitt in 1972. The advances here seem minimal and the novelty of the work remains unclear. The study would be more appropriate for a more specialised journal.

It looks like there will be an open postdoc position in my lab soon. I'll be looking for someone with substantial wet-lab experience in microbiology / microbial ecology / evolution / physiology. If everything goes well, an ad will be coming. But if you know someone, ask them to reach out already.

I'm curious if other mid career PIs have considered completely abandoning the trad publication model. We've been making gradual moves towards that end goal. But it's been difficult to completely jump ship for one main reason for me at least. 1/

As a junior researcher who is at the doorstep of the journal publishing system this post resonates with me a lot. Journal publishing looks like a historical contingency that's kept alive by the career promises that Nature publications make. thescientistpapers.substack.com/p/how-to-be-...

How to be a scientist in a post-journal world

When we created this site to write about things in science that need to be fixed, we chose not to start with publishing, even though it has been our preoccupation for decades.

thescientistpapers.substack.com