Richard Nicholls

@richardnicholls.net

He/Him, Podcaster, Award Winner, Liberal Lefty Humanist, Husband and Dad, Dancing Animal, 75% caffeine. Best Selling Author etc. richardnicholls.net/links

So many people who can't tackle their own clutter will sort a friend's house out in an afternoon, cheerful and decisive, no hesitation at all. Then they go home to their own pile and it's back to square one. Why is someone else's overwhelm so much easier?

Mess triggers shame. Shame triggers avoidance, because who wants to walk into a room that makes them feel like a failure? The pile grows, which triggers more shame next time. Telling someone to just be more disciplined only adds a log to that fire.

A patron told me she was mortified by her spare room, still full of boxes from a house move four years earlier. She runs her own business and never misses a deadline. She wasn't lazy. She was burnt out, with nothing left in the tank for her own home.

You can walk past the same pile for three weeks, feel the guilt of it every time, and neither part of you does anything about it. It stops being "I have a messy pile" and becomes "I'm the kind of person who can't deal with one". You are not broken.

That freeze you get looking at a messy room isn't laziness. It's your nervous system protecting itself from overload, the exact same machinery it would use for any other threat. Two hundred decisions with an empty tank, and it just shuts down.

Every single object in a messy room is a decision. Keep it, bin it, file it, fix it, give it away. Most of us can absorb a few without noticing. But 200 of them, with a decision making system already running on empty, and your brain just says nope.

Executive function is the name for the mental skills that run the admin department of your brain: task initiation, working memory, planning and sequencing, time perception, prioritising. Worth knowing which one is running on empty.

Cleaning, organising and decluttering get lumped together, but they ask completely different things of your brain. Cleaning is muscle memory. Organising is spatial. Decluttering is decision making, and it's usually decluttering people mean when they say they're overwhelmed.

If you've been told to just be more disciplined about the mess, here's a reframe. For a lot of people, clutter isn't a discipline problem. It's an executive dysfunction problem, which is a different thing entirely. New episode: Clutter & Overwhelm.