Steven Mazie

@stevenmazie.bsky.social

SCOTUS correspondent for The Economist. Political studies prof at Bard Early College-Manhattan.

President Trump had (loudly) promised that he would ask #SCOTUS to grant rehearing of its June 30 decision blocking his executive order purporting to limit birthright citizenship. The deadline for such a request was yesterday—and ... crickets.

NEW at SCOTUS: President Trump is back on the emergency docket with a plea to lift an injunction against his executive order “Ensuring Citizenship Verification and Integrity in Federal Elections"

Bild

Chief Justice Warren worked for months to turn a divided court into a 9-0 ruling announcing unequivocally that the 14th amendment bars racial segregation. 72 years later, Chief Justice Roberts wrote the decision affirming another bedrock principle of the 14th amendment—and the vote was 5-4.

The federal government was a party in 21 of the 56 merits cases #SCOTUS decided this term. All three Democratic appointees sided with the government in five of those 21 cases, and Justices Kagan and Sotomayor sided with the government in a sixth.

Aaron Rupar@atrupar.com · last mo.

Hassett on the Supreme Court's three liberal justices: "It can't be that Trump is always wrong. It can't be that Trump is always wrong, but that's how they voted."

Kavanaugh’s quasi-concurrence is in some ways more unsettling than the open dissents insofar as he contemplates a rather open-ended judicial prerogative to manufacture novel exceptions to birthright citizenship based on what are essentially policy considerations.

Two of Trump's three SCOTUS appointees ruled today that his EO on birthright citizenship is perfectly consistent with the 14th amendment. If he had picked, say, Ho or Oldham to replace RBG—rather than Barrett—we would have a different constitution today.

Apparently picking up on the implicit invitation in Justice Kavanaugh's concurrence, President Trump is asking Congress to turn his EO mangling birthright citizenship into a statute. He doesn't seem to clock the fact that five justices said today that the 14th am thwarts any such effort.

Bild