Sebastian Bodden

@tgmiles.bsky.social

Team Grün, Python/PHP, RetroGaming: Sierra & Lucas Arts Adventure, SSI RPG uvm Denken ist schwer, darum urteilen die meisten. C. G. Jung Image by: www.halhefner.com

"Game dev is one of those jobs you only do when you really want to. It's not going to make your parents proud, you're unlikely to get rich in an industry that lays off people for making superhits, and its a demanding & confrontative job. Why would you let a machine do the thing you're here to do?"

Austin Wood@woodwould.bsky.social · 2mo ago

I spent the last few months talking to over 30 game developers about generative AI. It began as a sort of interview survey but became a pretty comprehensive collection of arguments against the technology altogether. www.gamesradar.com/games/why-so...

🧵LLMs bringen die meist genannten Argumente zu einem Thema. Hedgen die mit haufenweise Relativierungen. In 77% der Fälle spiegeln sie dem Autor mindestens eins der Argumente, die er selbst gebracht hat & sie werden so abstrakt bzw. allgemein, dass ein Teil der Aussagen schon an Tautologien grenzt 1/

Examples from humans and llms for reasoning:
Human examples
Specific case “The case of Hurricane Sandy demonstrates that inadequate flood-protection studies and infrastruc-
ture investment, ...”
Specific cause-effect “Heavy-handed federal investment in drug enforcement has led to over half of the federal prison
population being incarcerated for drug offenses.”
Concrete solution “. . . could be prevented if companies implemented simple, low-cost measures like complex passwords
and frequent software patching.”
“Building bicycle lanes that are physically separated from car traffic is essential for ensuring the
safety of all demographics, including children.”

LLM examples
Generic citation “Research indicates that sex offenders have lower recidivism rates than other felons and that residency
restrictions do not actually reduce reoffending.” (by Claude)
Abstract concept “Cybersecurity failures create significant externalities where the damage of a breach extends far
beyond the responsible company to the general public.” (by Minimax)
Abstract solution “Crime laboratories should be independent from police and prosecutors to insulate analysts from
investigative pressure and cognitive bias.” (by GPT)
Hedged generality “A global framework must guarantee surrogates comprehensive medical care and long-term health
insurance to protect them from physical complications.” (by Gemini)
“Effective maternal care requires investing in a continuum of support, such as home-visiting programs
and practical assistance, rather than ...” (by DeepSeek)