As someone who's always wished academia was more like other types of work (as a grad student, I set my study hours as 9 to 5, M through F), I'd happily trade the entire star system in for good union jobs with solid pensions.
actually no I wouldn’t. we generally agree that if there was a star system it’s now gone for structural reasons—for better (solidarity! unions! collectives!) and worse (no material support). I balked when a UP editor was described as a starmaker in the NYer b/c I don’t think that’s how it works.