Pat Savage

@patrickesavage.bsky.social

Author: Comparative Musicology (academic.oup.com/book/62353; open access) Director: @compmusiclab.bsky.social Host/PI @manyvoices.bsky.social Rutherford Discovery Fellow @U Auckland Assoc. Prof. @Keio U Music, evolution, diversity He/him Tangata tiriti

This is so fucked up. Researchers rushed a gene-editing trial for a 6yo girl with a non-fatal condition, pressured the parents to illegally fund it, didn't tell them the treatment might kill her, promised not to publish their results in Nature, and did it anyway. Fucking criminals.

Pat Savage@patrickesavage.bsky.social · 23h ago

I cried reading this heartbreaking and outrageous report. The paper should be retracted and the researchers and hospital should receive a hell of a lot stronger sanction than a $4,000 fine.

I cried reading this heartbreaking and outrageous report. The paper should be retracted and the researchers and hospital should receive a hell of a lot stronger sanction than a $4,000 fine.

The paper had an enthusiastic reception. “These promising results might pave the way for the development of an effective clinical treatment,” Kevin Bender, a neuroscientist at UC San Francisco, wrote in an accompanying commentary. At the time, Bender had no idea that a girl had received it and was already dead. Meanwhile, Chinese state media, CCTV, called the work “the first ray of hope” for “countless families suffering such diseases.” Some families in Jason and Linda’s WeChat group said they planned to reach out to Qiu about their own children.

When Jason and Linda saw that, they decided to act. They submitted a complaint to the dean of Qiu’s university, demanding an investigation and a retraction of the Nature paper “to prevent more children from suffering and our blood and tears flowing in vain.”
John Travis@john-travis.bsky.social · yesterday

16 months after a young girl died in a gene-editing trial, the study's entry in clinicaltrial. gov has finally been updated to acknowledge the death. The move comes after @science.org and @retractionwatch.com revealed the fatality 1/ science.org/content/arti...

The Center for Scientific Integrity is proud to announce the inaugural winners of the 2026 Ctrl-Z Award. Named for the universal keyboard shortcut for “undo,” the Ctrl-Z Award this year honors @cetaceanneeded.bsky.social and @katelaskowski.bsky.social for choosing transparency over reputation.

ScienceAdviser Exclusive: Meet the inaugural winners of the Ctrl Z Award

Today in Science and science: Ice age hunters’ penchant for female mammoths, a detailed vagal map, and more

science.org

Heads up: what appears to be a scam/predatory academic organisation calling itself the International Institute of Music Science and Arts is setting up. Myself and other real scholars were emailed and told we were "appointed" as Fellows, but as far as I can tell...

Research page includes these apparently fabricated journals:

IMSA Academic Journals
IIMSA Journal of Music Science
Frequency

Quarterly

ISSN

2345-6789

Impact Factor

3.12

Scope

Music neuroscience, acoustics, psychology, AI, and technology

Submit a manuscript
IIMSA Journal of Music Arts & History
Frequency

Biannual

ISSN

2345-6790

Impact Factor

1.87

Scope

Music theory, history, ethnomusicology, and performance studies

Submit a manuscriptLeadership Team includes fabricated and/or misleading information (e.g., Prof. Robert Sterling as "former president of the American Musicological Society" who "has led IIMSA since 2018")

PostScript: I suspect that when asked further, Paul Henry will say something like "Well I was hit as a kid and I turned out alright" and I'm begging any mainstream politician to clip it and follow it up with "No, you turned into Paul Henry. We can't do that to kids, it's inhuman"

Obviously nothing has pissed me off quite as much as them killing the Marsden Fund (👉 my 📌 post), but govt claiming that the Science Investment Plan does not cut funding when the plan itself says “core science and research funding is projected to decline in future years” was the icing on the cake.

Luxon wants to ‘brutally commercialise’ science, but cuts threaten its foundation

Comment from Auckland University: Decades of research funding cannot be replaced by funding the commercialisation of that science

newsroom.co.nz

Loved @gene.meme's article on copyright issues in the ubiquitous "Gen Alpha Melody". However, as a musicologist researching copyright (academic.oup.com/book/62353/c...), I have to point out that the shared (non-copyrightable) chord progressions obscure a lot of (copyrightable) melodic variation.

Visualisation of comparative analysis of three examples shown in Carl Martin's "Gen Alpha Melody" YouTube video show that two are very similar ("It's Only Love" and "So Am I" 65% identical) while "APT" and "So Am I" are not so similar (34%).Examples of historical legal cases centred on melodic infringement. <45% identical melodies are usually not judged as infringing (green), while more than this can be judged infringing (red) or not, depending on context.
Gene Park@gene.meme · last wk.

your favorite song probably has the gen alpha melody that’s everywhere in music today www.washingtonpost.com/entertainmen...

I completely re-wrote the AI section of my guide to academic reading/writing to be much stricter and more negative (now titled "AI-generated fabrications as academic misconduct"). Please use/share with your students, and let me know if you have any more changes to suggest! doi.org/10.31234/osf...

Birdsongs give insight into evolution of vocal behaviour; global diversity may be key to develop unifying theories. @quentinbacquele.bsky.social & co studied song architecture in >3000 species, finding spatially varying equilibrium between environmental constraint & drive for complex communication.🧪

The global biogeography of passerine songs

Although bird songs are classic models for understanding the evolution of vocal communication, their global diversity has long made the development of a unifying framework challenging. By analyzing th...

science.org