Paul Julian

@swampthingpaul.bsky.social

#Aquatic & #wetland #ecologist, #biogeochemist & #limnologist but you will always find me in the #garden. #rstats number crunching fool. The trails call to me. #Plantbased #vegan muscle head at heart. Webpage and blog https://swampthingecology.org/

The peer-review system is so broken ... 1) I have a paper thats been in review for 194 days, the editor has so far invited 6 reviewers. 2) impactor factors are garbage 3) the statistics on days in review/acceptance, etc. are skewed 4) the system is biased (reviewer2 can tank the entire thing)

Hearing a peatland as "unmanaged and economically inactive" is strange to me. Having natural areas in of itself is economically active (ie ecotourism, conservation, water protection and security, etc). What it means no exploitation of natural capital (ie timber harvest, peat cutting, mining, etc).

New paper out in Freshwater Biology! We found that nutrient reductions in a hypereutrophic Québec lake led to a shift from colonial Microcystis toward filamentous Dolichospermum — a reminder that lake recovery is rarely simple. I 💚 working with stellar collaborators!! doi.org/10.1111/fwb....

Phytoplankton Regime Shift Toward Filamentous Cyanobacteria Following Nutrient Reductions in a Hypereutrophic Lake

Phytoplankton community responses to nutrient-management interventions in agricultural catchments remain poorly understood, particularly with respect to functional group transitions. Petit-lac-Sai...

doi.org

The Hawthorn (Crataegus spp.) has started blooming here in central NY!! In the UK, hawthorn typically blooms in May (giving it the name May Tree). It is also known to be an indicator of when it's time to plant temperature sensitive plants. We've been watching the trees in our woodland ... waiting.

BildBild

Catching up on Beechgrove Garden episodes, one episode did a segment on grass/lawn (after winter). The presenter mentioned grass/lawns have ecological value. Everything I've read & observed lawns have limited ecological value. Meanwhile grasses, not the monoculture lawn have ecological value.

Whilst writing up a new R-package I had my music playing in the background. This morning was a lovely couple of hours of @classicfm.com. So many great pieces ... This afternoon required a little more umph, "The Blood of Cu Chulainn" came on, that song always gives me goosebumps.

I love it when reviewers think they know what they are talking about to refute the paper but it turns out they dont ... don't challenage me on a statistical approach unless you made the method. If it made it into the paper, there was a lot of effort involved. Don't hate the GAM, hate the player. ;)

... somehow magically I got a pre-print rejected from a pre-print server because their screeners have determined that the manuscript type or its content is not suitable for posting as a preprint despite checking all the boxes and is required under the program we are working with. 🤦‍♂️

... and in the 11th hour reviewer #3 asks to include specific authors (but not references) in a manuscript to justify extending the discussion section of an already long paper. If these papers didn't make into the manuscript, you'd think there would be a reason. 😡

I don't think I'm anything special by any means (i.e. my 💩 does stink 😜😂 ), but I do feel like I should be doing more ... making more of a positive impact, being involved with more things, doing more things (professionally and personally). But not in a FOMO way if that makes sense.

1) With the plethora of data and more being collected with longer-term studies/analyses being developed, sampling frequency and data inventories are becoming more and more important to understand not only how the system has changed but how the monitoring has changed.