ashley_

@viviunderscore.bsky.social

ostensibly a writer, theoretically an artist, realistically just a girl who plays vidya games and sometimes screams about girls in rainwear minors dni

one day i'll find one of these anti-lala NSFW or twinwol harasser accounts/blocklist makers who's willing to actually face the question of what makes any of that more objectionable than being a fan of horror films or writing YA novels... (hint: none of them can provide a damn answer)

THE LALAFELL NSFW DEBATE IN A NUTSHELL
(thanks, high school debate classes):
Bailey - The harder to defend argument.
Motte - The easy to defend argument.
Too hard to prove the "bailey" argument?
Claim you were just making the "motte" argument all along!

Comment in a text bubble: Many people who claim to be against art/fiction being censored (or puritan ethics) still discriminate against  adult Lalafell players, especially those who ship or create NSFW art.
Many players report being hurt by related accusations.

Bailey argument against the comment: I feel that any Lalafell NSFW content is pedophilic, regardless of the stated age of the characters involved.
I will imply that anyone who engages with said works is doing so for covertly pedophilic reasons that apply to themselves IRL.
[Argument retreats to]
Motte argument: Stop pushing Lalafell NSFW onto us. I am allowed to be uncomfortable, that isn't censoring you!

OR (second example):

Comment in a text bubble: I'm a Lalafell player who has an adult character, ships, creates NSFW art, etc. If you are uncomfortable 
just block me. Do not harass us or claim without any evidence that we are groomers/pedos.
Bailey argument against the comment: Fictional depictions of shipping or sex can be generalized to IRL harm, or cause IRL harm. Because of that, I can draw direct comparisons between Lala NSFW and QoS, pedophilia, bigotry, etc. and it is also true that fictional visuals that cause me discomfort are morally harmful.
[Argument retreats to]
Motte argument: But it is true that Lalafell models are diminutive and "child-like." You can't argue with that, it's in official game text. We are just pointing out the official association!

In none of these cases are the motte and bailey arguments stating the same things.
No one cares if you are personally uncomfortable with NSFW 
of fantasy dwarf people. That's always been fine as a preference.Bild

i like going on the wolqotd feed but i see a good handful of questions lately that reference characters from before dawntrail and i have to keep looking at em like "i'm sorry but my wol wasn't born yet at that time"

as final fantasy xiv continues to get more new players over time, eventually we'll have an entire generation of players who signed up after "how very glib" was taken out of gaius's elevator speech i like to imagine those players will regard it as a mandela effect-esque mass hallucination we all had

Just got all my boys together to take on the wandering ronin who came to town. There’s like 15 of us and only one of him so pretty much the only thing that would give me any pause is if he was master of the devastating and lightning-fast iaidō style. But that’s not likely. Coward hasn’t even drawn h

i have no skin in the game re: RPing, but i just can't with people trying to create overly sanitized, kid-friendly fan spaces for a game that is neither sanitized nor kid-friendly. it betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the text when you fail to pick up on the real-world bigotry depicted in it