I would like to say I can’t believe a professional writing org would send out a message like this, but since I lived through the RWA implosion… 😬 And I agree with every point Chuck makes here, which is well worth the read! In short: writers write, they don’t prompt the plagiarism machine.
Professional writer organizations should not send out pro-AI propaganda in the form of tantrum-having "essays" to their members, and I don't think that's controversial.