Matthew Scarborough 𓀀

@mattitiahu.bsky.social

Philologist and historical linguist. Formerly UCPH, MPI-SHH, and Cambridge. Mostly Ancient Greek, comparative Indo-European, and nonsense. (ⲛ̄ⲧⲟϥ/ⲛ̄ⲧⲟⲟⲩ) https://orcid.org/0009-0001-1782-5223 https://brill.com/display/title/57781 https://iecor.clld.org/

Stumbling through head-over-heels through the Albanian internet trying to figure out whether some Greco-Albanian periodicals published in 19th century Alexandria have ever been digitised while still not *really* knowing how to read this stuff has been one way to spend my evening, I guess.

Greek verbs always have nice surprises: (ὀρύσσω, deep into the entry) "of a wrestler, dig into, gouge a tender part, τὠφθαλμώ Ar. Av. 442, cf. Pax 899, Philostr. VA 8.25; gouge out, ὀφθαλμὸν ὤρυττέν τις ὥσπερ ἰχθύος Antiph. 119." ==> Ready for anything the day may bring. 😎

The Odyssey is myth. It can take a beating. Unlike your 300s or Gladiators or Bravehearts or the like, "historical accuracy" is not a relevant parameter here. "Doing interesting things with the text" is.

188 μήδεα δ᾽ ὡς τὸ πρῶτον ἀποτμήξας ἀδάμαντι /mɛ́ːde̞a d ʰɔːs tò̞ prɔ̂ːto̞n apo̞tmɛ́ːksaːs adámanti/ And when at first having cut off the genitals with the adamant | – ⏑ ⏑ | – – | – ⏑ ⏑ | – – | – ⏑ ⏑ | – ⏑ |

187 Νύμφας θ᾽ ἃς Μελίας καλέουσ᾽ ἐπ᾽ ἀπείρονα γαῖαν. /númpʰaːs tʰ ʰàːs me̞líaːs kaléɔːs e̞p apéːro̞na gaîan/ And the Nymphs whom they call the Melians on the boundless earth | – – | – ⏑ ⏑ | – ⏑ ⏑ | – ⏑ ⏑ | – ⏑ ⏑ | – – |

Me: I wonder what Holger Pedersen was up to just before he went to Korfu to do fieldwork on Albanian... Ah yes, he's casually writing to Karl Verner about how he's just formulated what's nowadays called the RUKI rule in Slavic.

(Text in Danish)

BREV 25
Hr. Professor Verner.
Leipzig d. 20. Februar 1893
Jeg står nu lige på Nippet til at skulle afrejse fra Leipzig; i Begyndelsen af Marts tager jeg til Grækenland; Brugmann rejser også til Grækenland; han har foreslået mig, at vi følges ad. - Jeg har til »Indogermanische Forschungen« indleveret et nyt Arbejde med Titel »Das indogermani-sches s im Slavischen«. ') Jeg har heri udførlig begrundet følgende Lydlov: Det jafetiske s bliver efter i-, og u-Vokaler, i-og u-Diftonger, r, rog det velare q til ch, såfremt det ikke efterfølges af en stemmeløs eller stemt Explosiv. I alle andre Tilfælde bevares s. ch undergår følgende Foran-dringer: 1) det tager Del i begge de slaviske Palataliseringer 2) det falder bort foran n, m og ! - Virkelige Undtagelser fra denne Regel har jeg ikke fundet; Ordet běstъ, lit. baisüs gjorde i Begyndelsen Vanskelighed, indtil jeg opdagede, at det var beslægtet med lat. foedus og altså står for
*bhoid-su-. Hvor s og ch stod ved Siden af hinanden i Flexionselementer, er i en tidlig Periode ch bleven indført også efter a, e- og o- Vokaler, medens s efter Konsonanter holdt sig lige til den historiske Tid. - Af disse Forhold har jeg draget den Slutning, at det slaviske ch er opstået af et š.
Brugmann har bagefter meddelt mig, at Baudouin de Courtenay i sin Tid mundtlig har udtalt den samme Anskuelse, og en Bøhmer, som opholder sig her, meddeler mig, at også Zubatý nærer samme Mening, men ingen af dem har fremsat deres Anskuelse i Literaturen, og jeg har opdaget Lydloven uafhængigt af dem begge. - Jeg går i Afhandlingen endnu et Skridt videre og påviser, at dette förslaviske š har været tilstede i de selvsamme Tilfælde, i hvilke Indisk og Iranisk har š. Det har nemlig

Just going to say here, I think I've said this before, a 'historically accurate' version of the Odyssey is not possible because the Odyssey does not take place in a historical setting - it takes place in a fantastical pastiche of four centuries, mixed in with gods and monsters.

Watcher Guru@watcher.guru · 2w ago

JUST IN: Elon Musk says Grok will make a "full-length movie" of The Odyssey that is "historically accurate" by the end of this year.

Look I'm glad Homerists are having fun with it, but I'm disappointed that Indo-Europeanists didn't get nearly as much attention when the Fassbender-Robot got his head torn off while reconstructing some PIE sentences to communicate with some rather aggressive aliens in Prometheus (2012).

the most realistic scene in Jurassic Park is when two scientists make a questionable decision — traveling to an undisclosed location with a strange man — on the promise of three years of modest funding

For me the real intergenerational trauma I experience might be that I fear I won't be able to pass down my skills to the next generation because of how international university systems have decided to simply jettison entire disciplines of knowledge for being unprofitable.