Sesh Nadathur

@seshnadathur.bsky.social

Astronomer, Associate Professor of cosmology at Portsmouth. Works on galaxy redshift surveys, from telescopes on remote mountaintops or in space. Dad, occasional climber, likes cricket. Occasionally has opinions.

At Arundel today with a group of lads from my cricket club, watching Sussex v Essex. Very good turnout, in the 4000s I'd say. Festival atmosphere. Essex got 316/6, probably a good score but they looked on course for much more at one point!

It’s official: UKRI has defunded the LHCb upgrade, which would have run at the High Luminosity LHC (currently under construction). This is a disaster for UK physics. We’ve rightly invested heavily in the HL-LHC but without LHCb, we’re throwing away crucial science that can’t be done anywhere else.

Short-sighted, stupid cuts to the UKRI budget include shutting down Jodrell Bank, the icon of British astronomy. (Many other cuts too, including 20% to our brand new @vrubinobs.bsky.social). Interesting politically to shut down a major facility in...um..Manchester 🔭 www.bbc.co.uk/news/article...

Jodrell Bank's Lovell telescope faces axe in science cuts, BBC understands

Astronomers warn it would tear the heart out of UK science, and leave a generation untrained.

bbc.co.uk

While the Fields Medal celebrates the under-40s, the mathematician Joan Birman has, at the age of 99, solved a major open problem in representations of the Braid groups, a topic she has worked on for more than 60 years.

Graduation ceremony day for my former PhD student Dr Nathan Findlay! Nathan's (excellent) thesis was titled "Novel clustering methods for cosmology with the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument" and he defended it a few weeks ago.

Two men wearing academic doctoral gowns (one scarlet and blue, the other scarlet and purple with white trim) and hats, standing in front of a building with stone steps and pillars. One of them is also wearing a tartan kilt.

A Norway fan has gone viral for not taking part in their Row celebration after matches and won't do it if they win the World Cup "It’s factually wrong; they didn’t row, they sailed over the Atlantic”

BildBild

This is a good write up of the Nature anisotropy paper debacle. But while Sawala is right that it's unfair to the referees to expect them to have caught the big "elemental" mistake in the paper, he's also being very generous - there is another important error that the referees *should* have caught.

Lee Billings@leebillings.bsky.social · 4w ago

Now on @sciam.bsky.social: A recent paper in the high-profile journal Nature claimed what would've been an epochal revision to our understanding of the cosmos. Instead, independent follow-up work suggests the claim is wrong via a subtle-but-basic mistake. www.scientificamerican.com/article/phys...

A very general point: large-scale structure and #cosmology is now such a mature field that papers which – a. have a very new/exciting result, b. can be concisely written for a general audience, and c. are correct are vanishingly rare. But only the first 2 are non-negotiable for Nature papers! 🔭🧪

Sesh Nadathur@seshnadathur.bsky.social · last mo.

Last week a paper in Nature claimed a detection of Gpc-scale anisotropic cosmic structures, violating the basic principle on which all #cosmology is based: www.nature.com/articles/s41... This week, a preprint says they made an elementary coordinate mistake: arxiv.org/pdf/2607.01172 🔭🧪 🧵 1/? ⬇️

It’s also just a basic point about decency. Either calls for murdering minorities are a dealbreaker for you in using someone’s product or they aren’t. For Labour (and the Conservatives, and the Lib Dems, and Greens) they should be.