Q: Why is "give money" the right answer? A: Food banks get the *vast majority* of their donated items through grocery stores/wholesalers already, and those items are predictable; your cash lets them fill the gaps *themselves* between what's donated and what their clients actually need. Give money.
'Tis the season for bad advice on what to give to food banks. Here's mine: 99% of the time you should just give money.