Carylanne Joubert Maier

@carylanneejmaier.bsky.social

Bio B.Sc/GIS cert, writer, and current professor of English (MA). My children's books feature wolves, grizzly bears, panda bears, and research with greening in oranges. Lover of sharks, scuba diver, and future marine biologist. Avatar by Ethan Kocak

Hey Siri, show me a system that looks to filter out the scientific discoveries of women with seniority. The paper confirms the hostility many of us feel is baked into the editorial & peer review community (sitting behind a veil of anonymity) that prefer to see papers led by women thrown out.

Excerpt from the paper:

Gendered effects in peer review
At Science and Science Advances, manuscripts with women corresponding authors make up a gradually declining share from submission to review to acceptance (20.9% → 20.8% → 19.7% → 17.9% and 22.3% → 21.4% → 21.3% → 20.1%, respective-ly; Fig. 2B). Accounting for available covari-ates via multiple logistic regression reveals a small but statistically significant association with corresponding author gender in being sent to review or accepted after review (B =
-0.08, P < 0.001 for sent to review; B = -0.13, P
= 0.011 for accepted; tables S8 and S11).% plot of women’s representation among first authors (solid symbols), corresponding authors (open symbols), and among first-round peer reviewers (crossed symbols) over the evaluation process. Red line and symbols indicate the journal Science, blue indicating Sci Adv. all lines generally trending down from Submission stage, through editorial and peer review stages to acceptance stages.
Javi Ibarrondo@jibarrondo.bsky.social · 3w ago

Editorial and peer review dynamics at elite general science journals | Science Advances www.science.org/doi/10.1126/... 🧪

"don't cite what you haven't read" remains the basic entry level academic responsibility; & if your discpline "doesn't have that as a norm" then sorry, your discipline needs reforming for this new world. Citations are structural parts of trust and knowledge building, not trinkets or optional extras

Miles Klee 🦉@milesklee.bsky.social · 8mo ago

Academics and technologists are sounding the alarm about a growing crisis in scholarship as we know it: AI-generated citations of nonexistent papers that have infested real journals. Despite being fake, the sources are widely assumed to be authentic the more they appear in published literature.

The anatomy of an AI-supported academic article is becoming more apparent. I desk reviewed ~70 manuscripts this week for our journal. Reckon 20ish had significant AI assistance. On top of hundreds of others recently I'm starting to see patterns. Are other editors are seeing the same or similar? 1/

The Interior Department has canceled a rule meant to protect plants and animals that are determined to be threatened with extinction, the latest step by the Trump administration to dismantle key provisions of the landmark Endangered Species Act at the behest of industry. https://to.pbs.org/4f5A17a

U.S. cancels automatic protections for imperiled animals as critics warn of extinctions

Instead of receiving automatic protections, imperiled species will need individualized protection plans once they are added to the threatened species list.

to.pbs.org

🎬 LIGHTS, CAMERA, ACTION! 🍿 The British Museum for the world premier of the major new NatGeo/Disney+ show, #PompeiiOutOfTime with the very handsome, dapper, and downright lovely, Tom Hiddleston! Out next week, we got a sneak preview of the first two episodes. It's pretty epic tbh...🌋

A photo of five smiling people standing on a yellow carpet in front of a backdrop that says "Pompeii: Out of Time with Tom Hiddleston"A smiling Black man wearing black glass, dark jeans, a white tee and a brown jacket and boots. He is standing on a yellow carpet in front of the same backdrop as in the previous photoFive people sitting on a stage in white chairs in front of a large cinema screen. On the screen and lecturn front it says "Pompeii: Out of Time with Tom Hiddleton"An outstretched hand holding a small popcorn bucket on which is written "Pompeii: Out of Time with Tom Hiddleston"

New hope for coral restoration! Scientists still need to investigate why these 12 species are resistant to SCTLD, but it's a huge step forward. 🧪🦑 Mote Marine Laboratory finds disease-resistant coral that could help Florida reef restoration | FOX 13 Tampa Bay share.google/LHvlJoECO87i...

Mote Marine Laboratory finds disease-resistant coral that could help Florida reef restoration

Scientists at Mote Marine Laboratory have discovered disease-resistant coral strains that could prove vital to restoring Florida's severely depleted reef ecosystems. The breakthrough follows a four-ye...

share.google