Dr. Judith Scott-Clayton

@jscottclayton.bsky.social

Professor of Economics & Education at Teachers College. Affiliations: NBER, CCRC, former Senior Economist at CEA (2022-23). This is a personal account.

I’ve had two papers rejected in the past week, feeling a bit down about it. Come into work this AM & stop to re-read an article my kid wrote for their HS paper a couple years ago which I taped to my door, on our attachment to numbers (grades, scores… ie pubs, cites). So wise (excerpt in alt text).

…You could be comparing yourself to someone who is sacrificing their mental and physical health to maintain their "numbers." At the end of the day, it's not possible to know exactly how everyone else is doing-the only person who you truly spend every second with is yourself. That can make it really easy to feel like a failure, because how could a realistic picture of yourself compare to an incomplete and possibly romanticized picture of somebody else? 

…Here's something I wish I had known earlier, and something that I am still trying to believe: While test grades and exam scores feel relevant now, getting an 80 versus a 90 or a 90 versus an 100 will not have a significant impact on your life as a whole. When people remember your best qualities, they will think of your charm, intelligence, dedication, and kindness, not the exact number of books you've read this year or how many days you decided to rest instead of going to the gym….

"Better information, simpler applications, and clearer aid promises can move students toward higher-quality colleges. But they cannot create more high-quality seats." You can say the same about mentoring, advising, and pipeline programs. www.nber.org/papers/w35434

Degrees of Mobility: Shifting Low-Income Students to Higher Quality Colleges

Founded in 1920, the NBER is a private, non-profit, non-partisan organization dedicated to conducting economic research and to disseminating research findings among academics, public policy makers, an...

nber.org

Just submitted my public comment on OMB’s proposed “Uniform Guidance” rule, and saw that as of 11:59pm yesterday there were 341,699 comments submitted. That’s gotta be a record…? Wonder how many, like mine, will come in on the last day…

I made biscuits from scratch for the first time (for strawberry shortcake) and I know there are lots of ppl that do this all the time to a high level of skill but I’m just really proud that I did something new and I’m sure I screwed up multiple steps but it still tastes so frickin good!

I tuned into NY1 coverage last night just in time to hear Hakeem Jeffries respond to election returns by saying, “We are not in the business of winning…” followed by an excruciatingly long pause, after which I did not hear the rest of the sentence bc family commentary drowned him out 🤷🏻‍♀️

ICYMI (I did!): This story from @merkolodner.bsky.social last month brought me to tears, for many reasons. It will be so hard to repair trust in the Fedl govt, even after a change in admin. Still: People are tough, parents are tough. I am sad, angry, & hopeful ❤️‍🩹 hechingerreport.org/us-citizen-s...

U.S. citizen students face an agonizing choice: Affording college or protecting parents from deportation

‘I don't want to sacrifice my family for my possible success’

hechingerreport.org

At LGA too early on a Sunday morning and 1) kudos to the new design emphasis on a quiet & peaceful environment and 2) curses to those who thought it was a good idea to make phone w/o headphone jacks. The airport is so quiet, I can now hear people’s personal internet scroll from across the terminal

A million things going on in the world but my 14yo is playing piano and singing along to some Billie Eilish sheet music and while I suppose this is a fairly common skill, to get to appreciate it from my own kid in my own household on a random Thursday makes me feel like a trillionaire. 🥰