Peter Gainsford

@kiwihellenist.bsky.social

Kiwi Hellenist, Homerist, classicist, NZ. He/his/him/ia.

I'm a huge Emily Wilson fan She taught me ancient Greek. I've assigned her translations to my students. I interviewed her about translating the Odyssey a few weeks ago for my YouTube I'm not a fan of this review. And for what, I think, are good reasons (SPOILERS) /1

EMILY WILSON@emilyrcwilson.bsky.social · last wk.

I wrote about the Nolan Odyssey for the LRB. I'll summarize some of my main points below, in case you don't feel like reading all that. www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v4...

Rhea Receptions essay up, reviewing Nolan's "The Odyssey"! This thoughtful and insightful review considers the film as a product of our current times and places it within the historical lineup of other adaptations of the Odyssey over the past century.

Voyages in Time: The Odyssey (dir. Christopher Nolan, 2006)

Colin Whiting, Dumbarton Oaks, whitingc01@doaks.org Note: Spoilers ahead Let’s get the flotsam and jetsam of a film review out of the way first. Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey is, as one…

rheaclassicalreviews.com

[SPOILERS FOR 'THE ODYSSEY' (2026) AND 'ULYSSES' (1954)] It just occurred to me that the recognition between Odysseus and Telemachos happens exactly the same way in The Odyssey (2026) as in Ulisse (1954): Telemachos deduces his father's identity from the recognition scene with the dog Argos.

Still from the film 'Ulisse' (1954). Ulisse (Kirk Douglas) embraces Telemaco (Franco Interlenghi)

I love transplantations of myths, anachronisms galore. I can cope if someone wants to pretend Odysseus' visits to the sites of 7th century Greek colonies and trading partners are set in a quasi-historical 12th century. But a line like 'Our bronze age is collapsing' ... oh that's painful writing.

I am once again begging Hollywood to stop using the Greek alphabet for an Ancient World movie, if they can't afford to even throw a couple of quid at anyone with an inkling of the language. Unless they really think audiences are dying to see THS THDPSSSSPS

Bild

There have been 17 film adaptations of the Odyssey, or parts of it. No Greek actor has ever played Odysseus, Penelope, or Telemachos in any of them. Odysseus has been played by: - 5 American actors (Kirk Douglas, Harvey Keitel, George Clooney, Jason Patric, Matt Damon) ...

Still from the film 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?' (2000): Holly Hunter as Penny Wharvey-McGill and George Clooney as Ulysses Everett McGill

Homer's Odyssey has nothing to do with the Bronze Age. It's jam-packed with 8th-7th century BCE material; it has no Bronze Age material at all. This view is fairly standard among Homer scholars, but it's usually expressed cautiously. Sometimes it's a good idea to make it a bit more forceful.

History and the <i>Odyssey</i>

The Odyssey is not set in the Bronze Age. It is totally flooded with classical-era motifs, with a smattering of archaic touches.

kiwihellenist.blogspot.com

the study of the study of humanities and social sciences would reveal that they discovered what they set out to find, that social justice is what's wrong with the disciplines

The goals vary from area to area, but in a contemporary context they are generally though not exclusively associated with the progressive left. Put most broadly, the goal might be characterized as turning the humanities into vehicles for social justice, or the elimination of pernicious social hierarchies. More specific goals under this heading include anti-racism (the eradication of racial hierarchy), feminism (the rejection of patriarchy), the “decolonization” of the academy and of society more generally (undoing the legacy of imperialism), full equity for gender and sexual minorities and, to a much lesser extent, the eradication of class distinctions and the replacement of “neoliberal” capitalism with some form of socialism.

Question: when did the Romans stop using regnal years as a year count? Regnal years were still the standard in the time of Theoderic, as far as I can tell: did they carry on into the Lombard period, or did other systems become prevalent?

Third person pronouns are less common in ancient Greek than in modern English. Greek can express gender via adjectives and participles. You might expect the same would be true for Latin - but it turns out Latin uses 'is' and 'ille' _more_ than the English pronouns. Surprise!

A note on the language of gender transition in Catullus 63. Three years back I wrote a blog post on gendered language in translations of ancient texts. A different interpretation of Catullus 63.4 'vagus animis' now occurs to me.

I've been reading Phlegon's quotation from the Sibylline books. In 72 lines of hexameter (including the acrostics) there are 6 Attic correptions, and many metrical 'laws' violated: 16× Varro’s Bridge, 2× Hermann’s Bridge, 15× Meyer’s Laws (1× First, 7× Second, 7× Third), and 1× Tiedke-Meyer’s Law.

The following 17 words appear 56,819 times in the Iliad: δέ, ὁ, καί, τε, ἐγώ, εἰμί, ἐν, σύ, ὅς, μέν, ἄρα, ἄν, οὐ, ἐπί, γάρ, ἀλλά, and τις. They represent over half of the text of the Iliad (50.9% of all tokens), but only 0.3% of the vocabulary (5,448 types).

Well that's nice - episodes 1 and 3 of The Daleks' Master Plan (1965-66) have been recovered. 5 of the 12 episodes are now intact (episodes 1, 2, 3, 5, and 10). (I have a vested interest since one of the Doctor's companions in these episodes was an ancient Trojan)

Still of a clip shown on BBC, 13 March 2026

A note on Abaris of Hyperborea. The Souda (α.18) gives his name with the declension Ἄβαρις, Ἀβάριδος, but with an accusative plural Ἀβάρις (i.e. Ἀβάρῑς) 'by apocope'. Ἀβάρῑς isn't apocope. It's a double declension in ‑ιδ‑ and ‑ι‑, like Δικαιόπολις > gen. sg. Δικαιοπόλιδος, acc. sg. Δικαιόπολιν.

Oh for fuck's sake. I'm sure the science is fine, but this is an answer in search of a question. There's nothing to explain. There are NO ancient reports of 'beatific visions' or life-changing ecstatic experiences in the course of Eleusinian initiation: Kerényi made it up out of thin air in 1960.

Investigating the psychedelic hypothesis of kykeon, the sacred elixir of the Eleusinian Mysteries - Scientific Reports

This study revisits the hypothesis that Claviceps purpurea (Fr.) Tul., a fungus infecting cereals and producing ergot alkaloids (EAs), was the psychedelic agent in kykeon, the sacred elixir of the Ele...

nature.com