Rohan

@rohanps.bsky.social

Macroeconomist specialising in heterogeneous firms. Previously antitrust. Retired international sportsman / D1 athlete. Englishman in the US. An actual doctor, not one of those fake medical ones. https://sites.google.com/view/rohan-shah/home

Here's the AER editor trying to convince you how benign the use of AI is in the editorial process - "just a detailed technical proofreader." I've seen what AI does to students' behavior. Editors are no different. Once let it in the door, it will be asked to do all manner of stuff. e.g. desk rejects.

Erzo F.P. Luttmer@erzoluttmer.bsky.social · 3mo ago

1/5 AEA journals have run a pilot using Refine, and author reactions were overwhelmingly positive: >90% favored incorporating Refine into the editorial process. Think of Refine not as a referee, but as a detailed technical proofreader. @aeajournals.bsky.social #EconSky

Peer review is genuinely not a fraud detection mechanism and shouldn't be taken to be. It's not really a knock against a peer review system for failing to pick up when data is faked. The system is already over worked if we did data forensics at scale as a standard part of review it grinds to a halt.

Post nicht verfügbar.

Maybe this is spitting hairs but “social media attack” sounds somewhat petty or like bullying behavior, whereas what happened here is that people documented that there were serious errors in a paper and got stonewalled when they tried to go through the “normal” academic mechanisms for addressing it

3/ Examining the methods and code revealed a coding error caused by trying to include fixed effects perfectly collinear with the treatment. Correcting this error showed no effect of the reform on rape. We sent this partial replication to the author and journal.

Apparently Yanis Varoufakis thinks that Trump’s tariffs are based on a solid masterplan, which means that I have to update neither about the plan nor about Varoufakis.

In one fell swoop, Stephan Miran, Pierre Yared, and Kim Ruhl have destroyed not only their own reputations, but also those of anyone that has ever worked with them on any paper or other piece of work. I would be ashamed to have my name on the same project as theirs.

OBR forecasts are increasingly contentious; not only do they reflect Government policy, they increasingly shape it. The 2022 mini-budget fallout is the starkest example of the OBR’s impact. A 🧵on the pressure this puts on the OBR to get things right 👇

Bild