Shan Siddiqi

@shansiddiqi.bsky.social

Psychiatric neuroscientist (with capital Ψ, lowercase n) | Causal mapper of @braincircuits.bsky.social | Neuropsychiatrist | Asst Prof @harvard.edu | husband, father of a pure-bred Bengal cat and a 37.5% Bengal human

A recent @natneuro.nature.com paper analyzed lesion network mapping and raised concerns about the validity of the method. See below 👇 for our response. www.biorxiv.org/content/10.6...

Bild
Michael Fox@foxmdphd.bsky.social · 6mo ago

A recent paper in @natureportfolio.nature.com raised concerns about the lesion network mapping method. Our team of 16 coauthors analyzed >1000 lesions and 34 symptoms and found that "The methodological foundations of lesion network mapping remain sound" www.biorxiv.org/content/10.6...

I think the theoretical limit of explainable variance in a model should be less than the product of the test-retest reliabilities of the input variables. If the explained variance in a study exceeds that value (as it often does in the psychiatric literature), the model must be overfit.

Bild

What brain regions are involved in causing psychotic symptoms? Take a moment away from the existential dread about the future of science, and join me in this summary of some incredibly cool stuff that could help patients! 1/n🧵