Third Thoughts

@thirdthoughts.bsky.social

Ex-ac polisci. Queer & Enby. Ex-Catholic Jew. SF&F (especially Pratchett, Trek). 🏳️‍⚧️ rights are human rights. Nuance > Hot Takes. Youtube vids on political history and philosophy - https://www.youtube.com/@ThirdThoughtsYT

btw if you’re ticked at AIPAC for whatever reason them spending a maximum amount of money to barely lose is ideal, 10/10, just as a pure matter of don’t-know-ball and forward outcome for them as an organization. this cycle has been catastrophic for them purely in terms of inputs and outputs

I think my TLDR take on the Wilson-Nolan discourse is that Nolan's messaging is too Protestant in the details, and Wilson's critique is too "1800s imperialism decolonial" in the understanding of Greece.

This is a better critique than the first one, and I think gets at the core of Wilson's problem w/ Nolan - which is obvious from the intro to her translation - about the Greek colonization element of the original work. That said, I do think she reads too much 1800s colonization backwards to 600+BCE

EMILY WILSON@emilyrcwilson.bsky.social · yesterday

I wrote about the Trojan horse, and what we can learn from her mouth about different cultural attitudes towards deception and violence. As someone comments below, the phrase GIFT ARTICLE is pretty scary in this context.

The Odyssey is very good. Maybe the exposition dialogue was a little much, but - regardless of Wilson's criticism - I kinda like Odysseus as "prophet of his (and Greece's) own failures." Inaccurate, probably. But also it's hard to think of another hero who could fill that role.

like, "yes a bunch of people provided unharnessed LLMs and no guidance have cooked themselves" is not a particularly interesting observation. nor is "therefore the tool cannot be used for useful purposes" derived from that

Reflecting Pool lessons: 1. Trump administration lying is routine and pervasive. Nothing they say or do should have a "presumption of regularity." 2. They spend our money to prosecute innocent people. Congress should cut and restrict funds and hold liars accountable. www.nytimes.com/2026/07/31/u...

Charges Dropped Against Ex-Olympian David Hearn Accused of Damaging Reflecting Pool

A former Olympian will not face trial after federal prosecutors acknowledged that the Trump administration’s claims of vandalism were false.

nytimes.com