Doctor Who: Too Broad & Too Deep Podcast

@2broad2deeppod.bsky.social

Doctor Who Podcast on the Virgin New Adventure Novels, with Anthony Carroll & Alasdair Shaw! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

It was very exciting to have an Aussie writing for Dr Who! I remember Kate from the days she wrote letters into the local fanzine in the '80s! I recall reading this on the beach during a family camping holiday. A good book, but far from Kate's best work. 1/2

I think this is a strong start for Kate Orman but far from her best. In my opinion she reaches the upper echelon on doctor who authors with her EDA’s, but her Virgin output is still some of the best!

Thrilled to get a second invite back to Too Broad & Too Deep to discuss what I thought was a very underrated NA. This resulted in a very spirited discussion. Gratified to see so many podcasts covering the NAs now!

Doctor Who: Too Broad & Too Deep Podcast@2broad2deeppod.bsky.social · 4w ago

🚨NEW EPISODE 🚨 @dwtargetbc.bsky.social joins us to discuss Daniel Blythe's debut Doctor Who novel, The Dimension Riders - released November 1993! 👀 Listen below or on your app of choice 👇 www.podbean.com/ew/pb-i4drg-...

Cover of the dimension riders

Excellent/intriguing cover & title, an OK book in a mostly great arc. Love the Shada shout-outs/influence, the characterization of Bernice, 7 & Ace are pretty good IIRC, the story itself/supporting cast/actual writing are average at best. Very much 6/10 'cause I enjoy it despite its weaker aspects.

The Dimension Riders might be the most ‘Well, it’s not *bad*, but isn’t it a shame that…’ New Adventure Isn’t it a shame that name-checking Shada doesn’t let you off trying to be a grimdark Shada Isn’t it a shame that we’ve got a bit tired of ancient Time Lord-tie-in evils from the dawn of time

If you could only judge a book by its cover... Daniel Blythe does Shada, but replaces wit with laboured attempts at emotional depth. Tediously angsty, impossible to follow and a version of the Doctor that has nothing at all to like. (And don't get me started on Ace, the girl who wouldn't grow up...)

I had few memories from my original reading, but when I re-read it a few years ago I really enjoyed it! A solid space & time adventure, with good use of the Doctor. As I read it, I noted how many things from '90s TV it was referencing, only to realise it PRE-DATED all of them! Ahead of it's time.