Cuyler Keating

@cuylerkeating.bsky.social

She/Her | Cartoonist, Printmaker, & Graveyard Frequenter | https://cuylerkeating.com/ https://linktr.ee/cuylerkeating

I have now convinced three loved ones to try Kingdom Come Deliverance from my months-long, endless chattering about Henry of Skalitz. Let this be your sign if you need it that you should never be embarrassed/shut up about your favorite bullshit. You CAN change hearts and minds.

My comics practice is a constant see-saw between: This could be better, but I owe it to myself to just let go and get it finished. And: this could be better and I owe to myself to make it the best version of it can be.

Today in nominative determinism, there's a Hazardville, CT that I pass on I-91 and I've always wanted to know what the deal was there. Yesterday I find out that Hazardville used to be the site of the Hazard Powder Company, a major gunpowder and explosives manufacturer in the 19th century.

Had to drop Noah off at the bus station at 5am this morning, which was an excellent excuse to log some early morning studio time and dance to "Where Have All the Cowboys Gone" while making zines. Reprinting various "memento mori" things for the swiftly approaching fall.

BildBildBildBild

This post contains several thoughtful threads, and great conversation about how people can talk past each other because of misunderstood professional standards (on multiple sides), lack of context etc. I'm also very sorry to have posted without understanding the full picture.

Caitlin G. DeAngelis@caitlindeangelis.bsky.social · 2w ago

I'm taking down my shares and re-posts of Rachel Hope Cleeves' letter, but not without first apologizing for amplifying them. I trusted Cleeves, and I contributed to harm by sharing it without verifying her account of the matter.

What bugs me is how we as a comics community failed to defend not only Tillie but our art form. Including some prominent names who should have damn well known better. Very, very disappointing. If you haven't noticed, comics are under attack these days from many directions. We need to do better.

I’m ready to weigh in on the CHARITY & SYLVIA controversy. I’ve read both books and compared & contrasted them, and their sources. Is Tillie Walden’s book a rip off of Rachel Hope Cleves’ book, as the professor claims? No. It is not. #TillieWalden #graphicnovels buttondown.com/thene/archiv...

Charity and Sylvia: the extraordinary claims of Rachel Hope Cleves

In early July, a dispute began between two writers; Rachel Hope Cleves, author of Charity and Sylvia; A Same-Sex Marriage in Early America, (2014), and...

buttondown.com

i know when i sneakily steal someone's book to create an unauthorized and uncredited adaptation i always make sure to write "It is not possible for me to overstate how important Rachel Hope Cleves’ book on the subject was" and point readers "towards our Holy Mother of knowledge Rachel Hope Cleves"

thene@thene.bsky.social · 2w ago

out it goes: my long post about Rachel Hope Cleves's claim that Tillie Walden plagiarised her book. It's long because Cleves's claim is much, much more bizarre than it looked on first reading. I'm not going to bury the lede here. Cleves's claim does not hold up. buttondown.com/thene/archiv...

One of the (many) things that's depressed me about this whole situation regarding Charity and Sylvia is that Tillie's book is a masterpiece of comics work. @thene.bsky.social articulates it beautifully here. Tillie's book is beautiful, it's staggering, it absolutely stands on its own.

Bild

Deep dive into this bizarre controversy. I appreciate the close attention involved in this piece and it's more general conclusion: "But who even cares about facts or evidence when you’ve got a good grievance fantasy to ride? Just join the pile-on. It’s a lot easier than reading books."

thene@thene.bsky.social · 2w ago

out it goes: my long post about Rachel Hope Cleves's claim that Tillie Walden plagiarised her book. It's long because Cleves's claim is much, much more bizarre than it looked on first reading. I'm not going to bury the lede here. Cleves's claim does not hold up. buttondown.com/thene/archiv...

out it goes: my long post about Rachel Hope Cleves's claim that Tillie Walden plagiarised her book. It's long because Cleves's claim is much, much more bizarre than it looked on first reading. I'm not going to bury the lede here. Cleves's claim does not hold up. buttondown.com/thene/archiv...

stick a pin in this metaphor

…because these covers are a microcosm of the entire conflict; Walden's book is mostly built on writing and other objects left by Sylvia Drake, Charity Bryant, and others. Her work includes many elements from these records that Cleves does not refer to in her book, and many of her interpretations of those records are different from Cleves's interpretations, often intentionally so. In addition to her historical basis, Walden's book includes fictional dialogue and story elements that are original to her work, some of which are inspired by Walden's own life.
thene@thene.bsky.social · 3w ago

i am working on a very, very long blog post that could really have fit into a skeet: When someone posts that "this website/journal article/etc proves my dramatic claim!!!" and then does not link to the website, journal article, etc, it is because it does not in fact prove their dramatic claim.

The controversy over the Charity & Sylvia GNs has raised many issues about historical research and how non fiction GNs should handle citations, but the idea that it is a "rip off" is grossly unfair to Tillie Walden. I picked up a galley at ALA and this is 250 pages of densely reimagined storytelling

Sticking my nose into this to say that having heard Tillie speak publicly about the book multiple times, she openly acknowledges that Cleves' biography was a foundational text, and has dedicated an entire website www.charityandsylvia.com to a bibliography citing hers and Cleves' research.

Charity and Sylvia

charityandsylvia.com

Rachel Hope Cleves@rachelcleves.bsky.social · 2mo ago

An open letter, to readers, about Charity and Sylvia. I am very pained to feel the need to write this. #queerhistory #pride