Harper Jay

@dreamcastaway.bsky.social

fmr. community at Double Fine Productions | ex journalist (kotaku) | blue rogue | they/she | I write freelance stuff when the mood strikes

I think a hard thing for me to navigate as I've returned to on and off freelancing is the way in which the period of like 2005 to 2016 or something is just a gaping black hole? Which is to say I'm reeling by how much even "recent" history and notions of craft just completely faded into dust.

Everything a human being writes is subjective! Even and especially when they're making judgments about good and bad. A writer should confidently state what they believe. If everything is hedged with "I believe..." or "This is just my opinion but..." the writing is worse for it!

bolendo@bolendo.bsky.social · 21h ago

My problem with it is that it judges something as inherently more desirable than something else which is not a critique but a subjective judgment of quality And that’s cool but it also rightfully elicits the responses it gets Because people don’t want to be diminished and that’s fine

A genuinely interesting little patch that cleans up some language and terminology flubs in the remake. Those mistakes weren't the end of the world but fixing them ahead of SC (you got most of those actors in the booth!) is smart. Helpful in a series focused on long term worldbuilding.

GungHo@gungho-america.bsky.social · 4d ago

Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter Ver. 1.07 Legacy Patch featuring several changes to in-game terminology is now live. Thank you for your continued support. Full patch notes: loom.ly/nZ4NYlg

Me and my friends watched The Drama tonight and I genuinely feel like someone hit me in the face with a frozen fish. Amazing editing, a complex and messy script. Houhghhhh..😵‍💫

Game design isn’t about being able to identify problems. Everyone who plays games can identify problems. Game design is about diagnosing player experience, having intent, and executing. I think to a lot of folks outside dev, game criticism (an art in itself) is seen as interchangeable with design.

Riley Bruce@rileybruce.bsky.social · last wk.

What’s a thing from your area of expertise (or special interest) that you think it would behoove everyone else to know?

The more time has passed and I've let it really sink in, I actually am really surprised how much my fondness for Endwalker has grown in my heart? By all means I didn't dislike it! But thinking about that one two punch of Shadowbringers into 6.0 was pretty astounding.

I wrote a piece literally called "Games Criticism Is A Kindness" but paradoxically: that doesn't mean I think crit can't be mean. Criticism is human enterprise. Excess qualification saves you from mean commenters but it shaves off the human pieces. Sometimes a thing is bad, a behavior is wrong.

headfallsoff@headfallsoff.com · last wk.

one of the major changes in media criticism online in the last half decade is that when people used to do big leftist critiques of why harry potter sucks they always had a disclaimer like "now this doesn't mean i think you're a bad person for enjoying the books." they dont really do that any more