This has always been the animating principle of the anti birthright citizenship crowd, and the legal and historical ’analysis’ has always been downstream of it
Responding to @beaubaumann.bsky.social’s post today, Prof. Wurman deploys the same rhetoric used against every immigrant group in America. Is this racist, he asks? Judging whether one can be part of America based on a culture’s supposed "capacity" for self-governance is the structure of bigotry.