Tessera
Folgen

Review Commons

@reviewcommons.org

A platform by EMBO that provides independent peer review before journal submission for Refereed Preprints.

113 Posts1025 Follower886 Folgt
Review Commons@reviewcommons.org · 3mo ago

Study from the Ordonez group @ucam.edu showing how SLC33A1 enables ATF6α maturation, reshaping UPR signaling- now published @lsajournal.org #Preprintpeerreview by @reviewcommons.org Reviews and author's response available here👇(Reviews and Context>TRIP Peer reviews) doi.org/10.1101/2025...

doi.org

Life Science Alliance@lsajournal.org · 3mo ago

Read now: Metabolite import by SLC33A1 is required for ATF6 activation during endoplasmic reticulum stress @reviewcommons.org www.life-science-alliance.org/content/9/6/...

Duncan Sproul@sproullab.bsky.social · 4mo ago

Additional thanks to the editors and reviewers for the constructive revision process. Interestingly, we trialled AI review with @reviewcommons.org during this process. Overall we found that it was nitpicky and missed the big picture. Not a replacement for proper scientific review 🧵 8/9

Patryk Poliński@ppolinski.bsky.social · 6mo ago

Very happy to be the parto of this great initiative that involves young investigators in the peer review. A very promising start for this initiative at @embopress.org and @reviewcommons.org. Thanks to all the postdocs for brainstorming and the trainers for the encouragement! @embl.org @embo.org

EMBO@embo.org · 6mo ago

Yesterday, EMBO Press hosted a #webinar "Peer review in practice: Insights from EMBO Press editors" part of a pilot project in collaboration with EMBL, aimed at encouraging the engagement of postdocs in the #PeerReview process. 🧪 #LifeSciences #research

Pedro Beltrao@pedrobeltrao.bsky.social · 5mo ago

This is such a great and timely survey on author's perception of peer review vs AI scientific review. A collaboration between @reviewcommons.org and @qedscience.bsky.social. The geek in me would have liked to see the distributions in the response scores ;). link.springer.com/article/10.1...

How do authors want to use AI for review? - EMBO Reports

EMBO Reports - A survey of researchers who compared AI-generated scientific reviews with journal-agnostic human peer review reveals that they overwhelmingly prefer using AI as a self-checking tool...

link.springer.com

The EMBO Journal@embojournal.org · 4mo ago

Association of orphan nuclear receptors and heterochromatin are involved in Alternative Lengthening of Telomeres – Liuh-Yow Chen and coworkers identify their link as the transcriptional corepressor TRIM28 Thanks to @reviewcommons.org for another #RefereedPreprint link.springer.com/article/10.1...

Orphan nuclear receptors recruit TRIM28 to promote telomeric H3K9me3 for the ALT pathway - The EMBO Journal

Alternative lengthening of telomeres (ALT) is a telomere maintenance mechanism deployed in embryonic stem cells and cancer cells. High levels of the heterochromatin mark H3 lysine 9 trimethylation (H3...

link.springer.com

Sara Monaco@saramonaco-rc.bsky.social · 5mo ago

What happens if editors invite postdocs as referees? We have shown that we get rigorous, timely, high-quality reviews, and finally give young scientists the recognition they deserve. I’m proud to have contributed to this initiative with @reviewcommons.org, @embopress.org, @embo.org and @embl.org

EMBO@embo.org · 5mo ago

Learn about the new #EarlyCareer researcher #PeerReview initiative launched by EMBO: https://www.embo.org/features/embo-launches-early-career-researcher-peer-review-initiative/ 🧪

Thomas Lemberger@tlemberger.bsky.social · 5mo ago

It was a very cool experiment! The author-centric perspective makes a lot of sense. An important next step is to benchmark multiple AI review platforms. Maybe this can also pave the way for benchmarking human peer review across journals and defining "quality features" of the peer review process.

Oded Rechavi@odedrechavi.bsky.social · 5mo ago

It’s finally out! Together with @embopress.org and @reviewcommons.org, we conducted a structured side-by-side comparison of human peer review and our AI scientific review (see thread 👇👇👇🔥).

Daniel Ríos@yosoyden.bsky.social · 8mo ago

Our updated preprint is now out! The feedback from @reviewcommons.org was fantastic, we are very grateful to our reviewers for their suggestions. The last figure (plus other things) is product of this feedback and we're certain every point strengthened our work! www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1...

Adhesion to a common ECM mediates interdependence in tissue morphogenesis in Drosophila

For organs to be functional, the cells and tissues that constitute them must effectively interact with each other and coordinate their behaviours. Halfway during Drosophila embryogenesis, two lateral ...

biorxiv.org