Giles Sparrow is adrift in the vortex

@gswrites.bsky.social

Pop science writer/editor consultant for hire, specialising in astronomy and its history. Regular nerd with @somethingwho.bsky.social

Sometimes society at large rejects certain ideas because they’ve been thoroughly shown to be wrong and also because they suck and the people who espouse them suck and when someone comes around arguing those ideas should be part of some edgy modern debate we can and should shun them and move on.

much as the murder of Brianna Ghey mysteriously stopped being about the climate of transphobia in the UK and became about teen access to social media, the death of Jason Arday is, equally mysteriously, no longer about racism and is becoming about free speech in academia

We have had this conversation so many times. You do not have to platform/debate obscene views that are also false. I wrote during a wave of pressure on progressives to compromise with far-right haters:

I can comprehend, and do, that lots of people don’t believe climate change is real, but is there some great benefit in me listening, again, to those who refuse to listen to the global community of scientists and see the evidence before our eyes? A lot of why the right doesn’t “understand” climate change is that climate change tells us everything is connected, everything we do has far-reaching repercussions, and we’re responsible for the whole, a message at odds with their idealization of a version of freedom that smells a lot like disconnection and irresponsibility. But also climate denial is the result of fossil fuel companies and the politicians they bought spreading propaganda and lies for profit, and I understand that better than the people who believe it. If half of us believe the earth is flat, we do not make peace by settling on it being halfway between round and flat.
Patrick Sturgis@patricksturg.bsky.social · 2d ago

How about refuting them on theoretical and empirical grounds? That is kind of how science works. It doesn’t work by calling people names, refusing to engage with their claims and attempting to get them fired.

The idea that we need “intellectual diversity” in academia conflicts with the idea that the goal of some fields should be to learn actual truths. We don’t need to hire young earth creationists in geology departments, because the field has taught us young earth creationism is false.

Columnist Class hounding a Black academic for fun, over claims in his memoir that rudimentary research show to be true, doubling down because they've got a good anti "woke" narrative going now & falling over each other to defend the sweaty little white supremacist whose racist blog kicked it off

Palin in Death of Stalin, saying 'Rod Liddle would be loving this' instead of 'Stalin would be loving this'

Jarring and poignant to come across this Jason Arday event in the upcoming Cheltenham Literature Festval programme. The festival is sponsored by The Times and Sunday Times, which led the merciless pile-on to expose Arday’s plagiarism and fabulist claims. A case of having their cake and eating it?

Bild
Gerry Hassan@gerryhassan.bsky.social · last wk.

The industrial scale hounding of Jason Arday by the UK media is nearly off the chart. Figures from Newscord show 249 articles about Arday in the UK media in a matter of weeks with The Times leading the pack with 44 & Daily Telegraph at 43. A morally bankrupt industry.

I'm getting really bored of the persecuted crybully victim shit around this. You type into software. It's not an identity. The rest of us are having our work degraded and stolen for this and when these people aren't sobbing about being ostracised they're gloating about robbing us.

So we know AI helped a negligible number of students. But how many did it harm? I've crunched the raw data provided by the lead researcher, and what I've found is that ~9,500 students using AI studied less than even the *least* studious, non-AI using student. This should shock the conscience.

Bild
Benjamin Riley@benjaminjriley.bsky.social · 5d ago

Both the Economist and others suggest this study demonstrates that AI can help students. So I contacted the lead researcher to figure out how many. Answer: Out of ~26,000 kids, a total of 20. And five months after starting to use AI, only four continued to spend 65 minutes on homework. Four.

He may well have 1000 Einsteins and Mozarts working in his warehouses right now, but they can't do anything with their abilities what with having to work 18 hours a day under constant threat of being fired for taking a piss

@jaynitx
Jeff Bezos on why he wants a trillion
humans in the solar svstem
"I would love to see a trillion humans living
in the solar system. If we had a trillion
humans, we would have at any given time
a 1,000 Mozarts and a 1,000 Einsteins'
@propandco
Just pay your taxes bra

FFS. Not that you'd know it from the headline, but the death threats (surprise!) came from people ranting about "giving into wokes", NOT the initial critics. Also, LOL at claiming he's "keeping the memory alive". As if the history-industrial complex might ever give us a break from it.

LBC@lbc.co.uk · 4d ago

"My wife got death threats." The manager of Graveley Fruit Farm describes the 'intense' backlash around his Titanic-themed ride.

(AI actually has been used in science and medicine for decades and is incredibly good at doing things like finding cancer that can’t be seen with the human eye but that is a completely different type of AI then we’re all angry about it and we shouldn’t discuss them in the same conversations TBH)

Ben Collins@bencollins.bsky.social · 5d ago

Talk to the people who would use this for dream use cases — the cancer scientists, the people who want to make material goods out of it — and they will tell you it’s either a marginally useful if unreliable trick or completely useless. It has produced 0% of the utopian products promised.

Meanwhile, in the UK, serial asset strippers with a track record of such activity are closing down stores distributing comics and magazines across the country and there’s no sign of any government response…

Jordan Collver@jordancollver.bsky.social · last wk.

Popped into a random supermarket while waiting for bus in rural France and THIS was the comic book selection (and only part of it), the majority of titles I'd never even seen before. Magnifique.

Shelves full of french language comic books of all kinds.