I like these suggestions also for ARR and NLP conferences! Keep the rebuttal and score updates, remove the discussion, penalize reviewers who don’t update their scores.
Ok & kudos to @neuripsconf.bsky.social PCs 💪🏼 Diversity of trials is the best way to test what works & not. I doubt that any AI venue can claim to have nailed peer review at scale. Otherwise social media during review release & decision period would be 🌈💐