David J. DeVore

@devoretext.bsky.social

Ancient Mediterranean historian, Cal Poly Pomona. History, the human past (those 2 aren't the same), politics, some baseball. Views here not of my institution.

There are no laws of history. The analogous physical sciences aren't physics or chemistry, where there are laws, but evolutionary biology and historical geology, where you're explaining past events from partial evidence and so you can't simply model with equations or perform controlled experiments.

Americans have more confidence in higher education than in big tech companies, and the gap is growing rather than shrinking. The higher ed-doomsday pundits need to get on board with the real vibe shift in public trust that is happening right now.

BildBild
Mark Copelovitch@mcopelov.bsky.social · 2w ago

I look forward to all the reports & coverage about all of the internal problems & mistakes of all of these other institutions, in the same way that universities are constantly blamed (& blaming themselves) for “declining trust.” “Compared to what?” news.gallup.com/poll/712436/...

There is a lot to say about the Nolan Odyssey movie. But one point that I think has not been emphasized enough is: this is a film about living in LA, as Nolan, my erstwhile British compatriot and age mate, has done for years. I gather it’s a strange place.

I’m honoured & proud to be a new FBA — a member of an institution which is defending the value of the Social Sciences, Humanities and Arts in a period when they are increasingly under threat. These disciplines are crucial for a rich, deep and critical understanding of the world.

The British Academy@britishacademy.bsky.social · 3w ago

The British Academy has elected 92 new Fellows in recognition of their outstanding contributions to the humanities and social sciences. Congratulations to all those elected today. Read the full announcement: https://bit.ly/4f64C4x

Releasing public statements, covertly messaging on social media, trying to influence foreign leaders... Like diplomatic corps and intel agencies? Normal. Manipulating election and legal processes? Abnormal, worth countering. And as Trump just showed, the only country doing that to the US is Russia.

Will Sommer@willsommer.bsky.social · 3w ago

Trump's big document release tonight, supposedly meant to prove China stole the 2020 election, includes this classified intel graphic making clear that Russia was the only country trying to meddle in American voting systems.

The signing of the Declaration of Independence was just that. The war still needed to be won. A Constitution came later. Abolition of slaves later. The right of women to vote even later. All of us must finish and perfect our union. Happy Fourth of July, everybody.

Is there any good reason we should call the US founders “Founding Fathers,” the way Christians call early Christian writers “Church Fathers”? It accords familial/religious authority to some flawed albeit relatively publicly-interested men.

Every single publisher getting an AI payout from the LLM lawsuits should be paying it to their authors & making that author’s book open access—regardless of who own the rights. Most academic authors (ca. 80%) do not own their own publishing rights (especially first authors) & wont get checks at all.

1. An objective mindset & perception are impossible. 2. (1) doesn’t remove a shared reality of which observers have only partial knowledge & differing interpretations. That’s why analyses of the same evidence diverge. 3. Impartiality ≠ objectivity, & impartiality is possible.

Roopika Risam@roopikarisam.bsky.social · 2mo ago

If you think that criticizing objectivity means evidence should be irrelevant, you have no business being an humanist or any kind of academic.

Ancient historian thoughts on Iran mess. One thing that always struck me about the Hellenistic kingdoms is how quickly they surrender. These are kings who build up their whole self-definition about being good at war, but they quit as soon as they lose a battle.

Roman historian here. (The Romans perfected damnatio memoriae.) It wasn’t total erasure: the Romans would leave some reminder of the condemned name. If they scratched out an inscribed name, they’d leave the name partly visible still to recall terrors that person unleashed. How would we do the same?

Bill Kristol@billkristolbulwark.bsky.social · 2mo ago

Damnatio Memoriae Trumpi! It turns out this necessary task didn’t have to wait until January 20, 2029. It began at the Kennedy Center today.